Please take a moment to visit our sponsor's banner above! This helps us to pay for server fees. Thanks!
March to the Freedom Bowl
UHND.com - Russ Thorson
4/24/2002
Just for fun, a UHND.com visitor's proposed playoff system for college football:
Proposal: NCAA Division IA Football Tournament
Overview: 2 SUPER-ALLIANCES ~ 4 ROUNDS
16 TEAMS ~ 8 TEAMS PER ALLIANCE
7 MAJOR BOWLS ~ 3 CHAMPIONSHIP GAMES
Alignment: WESTERN COLLEGIATE FOOTBALL ALLIANCE
Pac-10/Big Ten/Big 12/Mountain West/WAC/Sun Belt
Rose Bowl~Fiesta Bowl~Holiday Bowl
EASTERN COLLEGIATE FOOTBALL ALLIANCE
ACC/SEC/Big East/Conf. USA/MAC/Major Independents
Orange Bowl~Sugar Bowl~Peach Bowl
1st Round: HOME FIELD ADVANTAGE
(Saturday after collegiate conference championships)
WESTERN ALLIANCEThe 4 highest ranked conference
champions, seeded #1-#4, stay home to host the 4 remaining highest
ranked teams, seeded #5-#8, in reverse order.
EASTERN ALLIANCESame as above. For balance, the major
independents take the place of a 6th conference, and the highest ranked
independent that of a conference champion.
2nd Round: NEW YEARS ~ 4 MAJOR BOWLS
WESTERN ALLIANCEThe 4 advancing teams are reseeded
#1-#4. #1 & #2 host #3 & #4, in reverse order, in the Rose Bowl
& the Fiesta Bowl. Pairings alternate bowls yearly.
EASTERN ALLIANCESame as above, in the Orange Bowl
& the Sugar Bowl.
3rd Round: SUPER-ALLIANCE CHAMPIONSHIPS (Mid-January)
WESTERN ALLIANCEThe 2 advancing teams are reseeded
#1 & #2. #1 hosts #2 in the Holiday Bowl.
EASTERN ALLIANCESame as above, in the Peach Bowl.
4th Round: NATIONAL CHAMPIONSHIP ~ THE FREEDOM BOWL
(Late January)
WESTERN ALLIANCE CHAMPIONS
vs.
EASTERN ALLIANCE CHAMPIONS
Rotated among these 6 bowl venues, alternating yearly between Western
& Eastern sites. Western CFA Champs host Western finals & Eastern
CFA Champs host Eastern finals.
The purpose of this plan is to provide a balanced playoff system that is fair and open to all NCAA Division IA schools and conferences. In light of 9/11, and the long-term impact on all of US, the FREEDOM BOWL would be appropriate for the National Championship, wherever the game is played. Time between rounds allows student-athletes to maintain academic requirements, if classes are in session, and better enables fans to make travel plans. Conference champions earn first round, home field advantage, because a conference championship is real, whereas a ranking alone is a collective guess, at best. After round one, eight quality teams are available for other, non-tournament bowls.