He shouldn't get a sixth year, either.

Anyone being at all rational won't buy the argument that moving to South Bend brought him significantly closer to Chicago for his family. He didn't fit in with Painter's system. Like it or dislike it, the point of granting the sixth year is to reward those who lost a couple years due to injuries or extreme circumstances. He lost one year due to the transfer and one due to injuries. He got his fifth year and that should be it.