Notre Dame Justified In Ending Their Pursuit Of Mike Elko

The man said yes.

Upon hearing the news former defensive coordinator Mike Elko was on his way to Texas A&M for the same position, the initial reaction for many, myself included, was Notre Dame let him get away. The implication was Notre Dame wasn’t willing to pony up the money to retain their hire from a season before.

But, as more details emerged, that showed not to have been the case.

Eric Hansen of the South Bend Tribune reported last Thursday Mike Elko had agreed to a new deal with Notre Dame that would pay him about 1.5 million per season. That would put him as the third highest paid assistant coach in the nation, behind only Dave Aranda at LSU, and Brent Venables at Clemson. It’s hard to say Notre Dame wasn’t willing to pay what’s necessary when they were willing to go top 3 for a first year head coach who achieved very good results in his first season, but also didn’t light the world on fire. His unit also faltered some in the final month of the season, but it just wasn’t as glaring as the struggles on offense.

The defense fell from 337 yards per game and 4.7 yards per play to 401 yards per game and 5.4 yards per play. They also saw significant drops during the final five games in points per contest (15 to 25), sacks(19 to 5), and turnovers gained (18 to 2).

Notre Dame was substantially better in a lot of ways throughout the season that don’t show up on stat sheets, improved tackling and being assignment sound for example, so I don’t want to make it seem as though it was smoke and mirrors in the first two months. But, it’s fair to point out the defense, like the offense, saw a drop in play while the team overall struggled.

This all matters in the context of Notre Dame deciding whether or not it was worth it to renegotiate the contract for a third time and make Elko the second highest paid coordinator in all of college football. Especially when Elko had already said yes to a new deal.

Elko Agreed To A New Deal

The most significant detail in the Hansen story is Elko had verbally agreed to a new contract with Notre Dame, for an aforementioned 1.5 million per season. Business is business and I think most people can understand that. Nothing is done till something is signed, something we see in recruiting all of the time, so Elko is free to do whatever he thinks is best for him and his career.

But, it’s certainly understandable why Notre Dame would balk to renegotiate again when A.) they’ve already given Elko a raise to make him college football’s third highest coordinator and B.) he’s already said yes to that deal. This isn’t a situation where Notre Dame made a bid and A&M made a bid, and Elko chose the higher bid. Elko agreed to the terms Notre Dame made. Then he went back to Texas A&M. That is something that would give anyone pause, business decision or not.

Where does this end? If Notre Dame matches, does A&M make it 2 million? 2.3 million? How invested is Elko in coaching at Notre Dame if he is just going to the highest bidder?

Another thing to consider is whether Notre Dame is going through the same thing next year, not just for other coordinator positions, but a head coaching position. Also, this would be a heck of a precedent to set for another high level coordinator who comes along, whenever that might be and whoever the head coach is. At some point it’s necessary for Notre Dame to say “we offered a deal and a raise, and you said yes, you don’t get to come back and ask for more after you’ve made an agreement.”

Elko Isn’t The Only Coach On The Block

Elko was a good hire, no question, and no one wanted him to leave. There was panic and stress for good reason. But, it’s important to remember he’s not the only one who knows how to coach defense, and it’s time for Kelly to make another good hire, because this is a part of his job description. When you hire good coaches, they leave, for a variety of reasons.

Kelly probably didn’t imagine he’d be looking so soon, but that’s the way it goes. It’s incumbent on him to find the right coach for the situation and move the team forward.

But, as for this situation and the way Elko was handled. It’s hard to find fault with how Notre Dame handled it. After all, the man said yes.

You may also like

105 comments

  1. Bruce Gregory Curme 5 months ago

    Did that catch at the end of the Vikings game remind anyone else of the Citrus Bowl catch? Strange. It’s something you never see actually work, then you see it twice in as many weeks!

    Tillery will be a household name in American football well before this time next year. Smart move on his part all around. Get that man some insurance (if that is still allowed by NCAA).

    BGC ’77 ’82

    Reply Like Dislike
  2. Michael the Archangel 5 months ago

    Tillery to return for Senior season.

    https://247sports.com/college/notre-dame/Article/Jerry-Tillery-to-return-for-senior-year-113671045

    Still waiting on Coney decision.

    Reply Like Dislike
    1. duranko 5 months ago

      Michael, this is massive. I want Coney back too, but Tillery would have left a disaster on the DL. Now they can use tagaviloa, Hinish and Ewell in the two deep until Ademilola and Franklin are ready. Dew-treadway and Tiassum are soybean filler, nothing more. One would CONJECTURE (ever dangerous) that Ademilola and Franklin would be more ready to play than Hinish and Myron.

      But we need FOUR defensive tackles in the ’19 recruiting class. Nothing less.

      Coney would stabilize the LBS and one could conjecture, with the returning talent, that each of the position groups:

      DL
      LB
      S/Rov*****
      CB
      would have more talent experience and depth than the ’17 version.

      ***one would expect the safeties to improve the most

      Plus they have real game and 10game winning experience in the 4-2-5.

      Could be fun.

      Reply Like Dislike
      1. Michael the Archangel 5 months ago
        Like Dislike
    2. duranko 5 months ago

      One other thing with coney back, this will give some added time for development of Lamb, Bauer, Oghoufo and, I hope (slim) Tuliapupu

      Noted dim bulb Tom Loy talked about a three man tackle rotation. What a numbskull. To be great (think GA, Bama, Clemson, Ohio State) you have to have a five man tackle rotation and five at DE.

      That’s the minimum to play with the big guys.

      Reply Like Dislike
    3. southside 5 months ago

      MTA , thank you for the breaking great news I awoke to this morning at 5am .

      Reply Like Dislike
  3. duranko 5 months ago

    And Seven early enrollees are scheduled to arrive on campus today, Sunday, Jan. 14th.

    Lot of lumber and athleticism at linebacker with Lamb, Oghoufo and Bo Bauer

    Griffith is added to the secondary.

    Tall George Takacs to the TE corp

    Micah Jones, a faster Miles Boykin, rolls into the WR cadre.

    And JahMir Smith will mesh with Autry Denson at RB.

    that ain’t bad

    Reply Like Dislike
  4. duranio 5 months ago

    And Seven early enrollees are scheduled to arrive on campus today, Sunday, Jan. 14th.

    Lot of lumber and athleticism at linebacker with Lamb, Oghoufo and Bo Bauer

    Griffith is added to the secondary.

    Takacs to the TE corp

    Micah Jones, a faster Miles Boykin, rolls into the WR cadre.

    And JahMir Smith will mesh with Autry Denson at RB.

    that ain’t bad

    Reply Like Dislike
  5. Bruce Gregory Curme 5 months ago

    C-Dog,
    It’s always been easy to tell that you’re from the ND family. As for the historic mission of ND, well, it was founded by French priests to serve socially oppressed Irish (and other) Catholics in what was then an ethnically French community, as part of an American missionary effort. America, last I heard, is still classified by the Church as a missionary land (though that might have changed recently). The mission of the Public Relations, Fund Raising and Development Offices was, and I think still is, “To bring Notre Dame to the world, and the world to Notre Dame.”

    Is winning a football championship an important part of that mission? Well, that’s debatable, I suppose. It may surprise some of you to know that I think it is an important part – but for historical and social reasons, not intrinsically. Notre Dame was here carrying out its mission before football was invented, and will certainly be here long after football is an afterthought for the species. But in the meanwhile, our players and coaches need to continue building on the achievements of this year – and win a NC…as long as we play the game, we ought to win at least one NC per generation…and that hasn’t happened.

    Bruce G. Curme ’77 ’82

    Reply Like Dislike
    1. C-Dog 5 months ago

      Bruce,
      I love what you just wrote. Yes. And that’s why it’s important for Notre Dame fans to always keep in mind that just winning isn’t enough. It’s how the Irish win. That means how Notre Dame runs its program. Individual athletes should not be put a pedestal, but should on the whole be applauded for how they conduct themselves as citizens and in the classroom. The reason to try to win a national championship is to promote a higher bar of ethics in sports and beyond.
      But you also touched on the other reason Notre Dame Football was important which was to show that bigotry can be overcome not by whining or lowering the bar but by achievement. That story can be told today and Notre Dame could tell that story if it can win some championships.

      Reply Like Dislike
      1. Bruce Gregory Curme 5 months ago

        C-Dog,
        And if we win the right way, we are valuable to the mission. If we win like everybody else wins, we are simply like everybody else! What is gained for the Lady on the Dome by that?

        Guys like David, and BJ before him, are right when they say that ND winning big ratifies a whole bunch of stuff that ND has always stood for – a relentless pursuit of excellence in life as well as on the field especially comes to mind. Showing the “true spirit” of Notre Dame (something Coach Holtz was consumed with) also comes to mind. The difference between us on this is that I happen to think BK has taken his players some huge steps in getting back to that kind of place. Is there more to do? Yes, for sure. In 1929 (I think it was), Rockne played every game on the road…and won every game! We have not exactly been road warriors lately, and we will never see the playoffs if we don’t fix that. The Citrus Bowl was a great start on that.

        What sticks in my craw though is people who don’t give these guys and coaches the credit they are due for the endless hours of hard work they put in WHILE keeping up their studies to ND levels of satisfaction…and they are not ball room dancing. Speaking for myself, I had to devote all but 1 hour at lunch per day (when I was either in the PIT playing B-ball, or at Mass at Sacred Heart) every day, all year long (I always took two summer session courses) just to get my 3.3 as an undergraduate! I don’t know how those guys and gals in any of the sports do it! They are some of the finest people this society has ever produced…and in the longest of views, not the most shortsighted, cranking them out year after year to serve God, Country, and Notre Dame is the essence of the mission. And yes, we crank out a “misfire” (even a miscreant) now and then…but the results, overall, speak for themselves.

        BGC ’77 ’82

        Like Dislike
  6. Ron Burgundy 5 months ago

    Quenton definitely thought LONG and HARD about staying…AGAIN.

    I will bring you back to the day after the Echo Awards over a year ago when Q faced the very same decision. After listening to the people who really knew what they were talking about tell Q that he needs to leave, that there were very few good QB’s in the 2017 draft, even fewer good Offensive Lineman and that he would definitely go anywhere between the late teens and mid twenties, it was Brian Kelly’s turn to tell Quenton why he should return to ND for the 2017 season.

    I can tell you in all honesty that we sat before a very tired and humbled head coach who began our discussion by taking full responsibility for the horrific season that was. He took his time listing all of the mistakes and faults he felt he personally had made, and in great detail, before even attempting to give Q a reason to return. He encouraged Quenton to come back and get his degree but more importantly he wanted Q to return to work on his leadership skills and become a larger part of a Notre Dame football program in which he promised “huge changes” and where “no stone would be left unturned”.

    I don’t believe anyone can really appreciate the vast amounts of the strategic thinking and self reflection that Brian Kelly had to have made… in a very short amount of time… to transform the heart and culture of this team. But, as for Q, fortunately he had a front row seat.

    From brutally honest player exit interviews and the early naming of vocal team leaders, BK had to get rid of the demeaning, under performing coaches (some of whom he had long personal ties to) and identify AND hire the “right kind of guys” like Long, Elko, Balis, and Polian who wanted to actually recruit and teach student athletes at Notre Dame. Coaches who would get totally in your face one day, but more importantly have their arm around you the next.

    BK then had to get these new coaches all on the same same page to hold together the 2017 recruiting class together, while building an even stronger class for 2018. The Balis winter program was pure hell, but welcomed by a group of players wanted to put the travesty that was the prior season behind them. There were SWAT teams, over the top competitions and individual player accountability that reached out far beyond the weight room in the Gug.

    BK turned to technology to monitor sleep and practice performance, hired Dr. Selking to help provide a psychological edge and a more simplified and consistent message between his staff and the players. There was a deeply rooted belief that thoughts control emotions which controls response and dictates performance.

    All of these new coaches, new offensive schemes, defensive schemes,staff members, ideas and initiatives and just a few short months to bring them all together. How were these new coaches, who themselves had never worked together before, going to get over 100 players to buy in, and get them up to speed before facing Temple, Georgia at home, BC and Michigan State on the road to begin a season? Good luck with that!. And yet, I recall Q calling me after camp at Culver and telling me how much more “great coaching was going on” and how the work ethic and accountability that had been present in the winter workouts and spring ball had manifested itself into the summer.

    Perhaps the greatest transformation of all came from coach Kelly himself. He had told us in that meeting that he had a burning desire to shed the public appearances and fund raising activities that demanded so much of his time and get back to being with his players. To his word, he was there at the Gug for the 4:30 a.m. lifts, had lunch, sometimes dinner with the players and established the types of relationships a coach in search of National Championships needs to have with his players. He had gotten out of the tower and into the trenches to become a coach that his players WANTED to WIN FOR. As Shawn Crawford was quoted as saying during one of the TV broadcasts this season, Coach Kelly had become that same guy who had recruited him in his living room during his in home visit.

    I think the single toughest thing Coach Kelly did was one that, as a former coach, I don’t think I could have even done. How much balls did it take for a coach who is probably on the hottest seat in college football to turn over the play calling, “the keys to the car”, to a new OC that he had never even worked with before. Even IF JS had something to do with that decision as others have speculated, BK still had to check his ego at the door, go with it and damn well do it.

    There are those on this board who are not particularly thrilled with ND going 10-3 from 4-8 and those who still believe that there is a “better man out there to lead ND back to their glory days”. I would ask you WHO?, and don’t give me the Urban Meyer, Nick Saban BS. First of all, Urban flat out told Q that he would “hate South Bend” and that his wife refused to go back and live there and would flat out not let him take the position when it was offered AND neither one of them could or would coach here under the rules, restrictions requirements and standards that are Notre Dame.

    Ironically, it was these very standards, the quality of players, the coaches and Notre Dame itself that made Q think long and hard about staying……

    AGAIN. How do you leave all of your brothers behind and say goodbye to the best Offensive Line Coach in college football (that people on this board and others still question and complain about) How do you thank a man who gave all that he had, did all that he promised and left no stone unturned?

    I think everyone would agree that we got beat by 1 point by a VERY GOOD Georgia team. We were totally not prepared for the environment that was Hard Rock, and leading 20 – 17, we could not overcome 3 turnovers in the fourth quarter vs. Stanford. It’s that simple AND we were that close. Not bad for a team that was in total shambles one year ago.

    I believe that this past season was “just the first coat of paint” and that Notre Dame football is headed in the right direction, led by a man who would be very difficult to replace. Think about this for a moment: How does a leader become a “players coach” while at the very same time demanding far more of his players than EVER BEFORE? This is what occurred, this is something to build on.

    If I had only one last thing to say, it would be to sincerely thank all of the coaches, and teammates that Quenton leaves behind. If I had one more wish, it would be that the fans, readers and posters on this forum stand more firmly behind these very same coaches, and players who work so damn hard and hate to lose even more than you do.

    CAN’T WAIT FOR MICHIGAN…LOVE THEE ALWAYS

    Reply Like Dislike
    1. Bruce Gregory Curme 5 months ago

      My turn for brevity Burgundy: You just said it all, brother.

      BGC ’77 ’82

      Reply Like Dislike
    2. Ron Burgundy 5 months ago

      the above is a letter from Q’s dad, saw it on another board

      Reply Like Dislike
      1. david 5 months ago

        Bruce Gregory is trying to keep up, God bless his cotton socks.

        Like Dislike
    3. Damian 5 months ago

      How the players view their coach is important. They have to believe, and in college like their coach to want to put themselves on the line. I obviously have my issues with BK, but there’s no doubt he connected with his players on a much deeper level this year. As a fan, I just want to see ND respected again (which I must admit they are) and the holy grail, be elite again.

      When I see comments by players sometimes it makes me think I ought to just shut my mouth and stop whining. But at the same time, the ole “maybe next year” just gets old. Every year many of us say, well maybe next year will be the year. I just wish, for once, next year would become this year.

      In any event, I’ll continue to root for the Irish. I won’t let BK get in the way of me wishing for a win every game.

      Go Irish!

      Reply Like Dislike
    4. david 5 months ago

      And the beat goes on.

      Reply Like Dislike
  7. Michael the Archangel 5 months ago

    Harry Hiestand headed to the Bears. Clark Lea promoted to DC. Elston stays as associate head coach, giving him more administrative duties and hopefully a raise.
    I suspect Polian will now become the recruiting co-ordinator replacing Elston. ND will now need a Safeties’ coach and an OL coach. “The only constant is change.”

    Reply Like Dislike
    1. southside 5 months ago

      Thank you MTA for the update on latest ND news. I went to Notre Dame Insider(South Bend Tribune) this morning–plenty of info on latest ND news. I think the hiring of Lea as DC and the promotion of Elston to upper level as Co-HC was the best move by Kelly and the doing it asap was imperative–preventing a worse situiation of both leaving. If that happened — things would be in dire straits replacing a DC , a D-line coach and Linebacker coach. These are the guys that coach “trench warfare”–the front 7 on D. The next big news coming up will be soon—whether Coney and Tillery are going to stay put or go to NFL.

      Reply Like Dislike
      1. southside 5 months ago

        Another thanks to MTA—Yet posters don’t give a shit — more concerned with their own self input about “the status of ND football.”

        Like Dislike
  8. duranko 5 months ago

    Notre Dame defensive tackle recruit Jamion Franklin is donating stem cells to help try to save his Dad’s life.

    Were he never to play a down at Notre Dame, were he never to make a tackle, I would be honored, truly if Jamion allowed me to call him my Notre Dame brother.

    For Jamion, for the biblically oriented among you, is the antonym of “corfam.”

    Reply Like Dislike
  9. C-Dog 5 months ago

    The promotion of Lea and of Elston, might just be what they need. I won’t cry about it. The ND culture is unique so promoting from within makes sense.

    Hey on a side note did anyone see the OneFoot Down is promoting 21 Notre Dame championships in light of UCF and the SEC teams? I love it. Why not? I was at the Catholics versus Criminoles in 1993 and no way does FSU deserve it over Notre Dame. Plus FSU went on probation right after that

    Reply Like Dislike
    1. david 5 months ago

      Another happy nostalgia consumer.

      Reply Like Dislike
    2. southside 5 months ago

      Agree C-Dog. Going “In House” for/keeping Lea and Elston leading 2018 defense is best move.

      Reply Like Dislike
      1. david 5 months ago

        Emergency money got approved for the shotgun negotiation….it’s now just getting doled out as damage control instead.
        But you spin it how you like.

        Like Dislike
  10. PJ 5 months ago

    We are a bit over reacting about our defense. The VanGorder situation has the fans a but out of sinc. The very first thing that happened after Vangorder was fired was that the defense improved just with simplification. The second thing was a few players began tackling better by wrapping up the runner. One on one tackling improved significantly in 2017. Our speed on defense improved and this included recognition reaction time. Offense improvement always helps the defense. As offense faltered more pressure fell on the defense. We played a very tough schedule. 7 opponents ended up in the top 25 this year. The defense will be even stronger next year as more players are experienced and the defense is no longer brand new. Relax.

    Reply Like Dislike
    1. Jeff 5 months ago

      The injury bug did not hit the defense this year like it has in the past. Another reason for the improvement this year.

      Reply Like Dislike
  11. duranko 5 months ago

    The board Chicken Littles, including the clerks from FIU went FullTILT SKYFALL when Tony Alford and Kerry Cooks left.

    Then came Autry Denson and Todd Lyght.

    Denson has rebuilt the running back cadre without chasing some of the knuckleheads that Alford was infatuated with.

    Lyght, in the ’16 class performed one of the great DB recruiting coups in ND history, and is a Boykin/Irivin away from duplicating
    that in ’18, after having survived the Van Gorder meltdown in ’17.

    So Clark Lea is now the DC.

    And we will see who the new safety coach is………..

    (We are now interrupted by someone channeling his innner Chicken Little:

    Kelly can’t recruit!
    I hate the uniforms
    Ara never lost and never went 1000 days without beating Purdue and USC
    Mekhi Brown the coach shover and Bama won the NC
    I hate the field
    Holtz never lost
    I hate the scoreboard
    A&M has more esteem (and oil money, thank you, Bum Bright) than ND
    I hate EVERYTHING about ND footballl, but my sadomasochism keeps me here!!!
    Life changes, sports changes! Waah!

    Notre Dame is more interested in graduating players and having quality kids like Student Body President David Robinson
    try to uphold the student-athlete mantra than winning games and satisfying my weak ego!) Notre Dame would rather populate its
    program with former players like Denson, Lyght, Grimes, Powlus and Brooks than in bringin scum like Kiffin and Locksley!

    Woe is me! I want championships and nobody is paying attention! Waah!)

    And this concludes our channeling of the board chicken littles including the clerk from FIU!

    Reply Like Dislike
    1. david 5 months ago

      Graduation. The moral high ground deflection in any debate on the utter suckitude of ND football.

      BTW….where’s the website messageboard for 24/7 coverage of ND graduation news?

      Reply Like Dislike
      1. C-Dog 5 months ago

        Man Up dude and tell isn’t whether you are a fan or a troll and who you actually root for.
        Otherwise you’ll get destroyed and humiliated like all the trolls before you.
        Man up and you might get a little respect.
        With all your criticisms of everyone else, why are you here?

        Like Dislike
      2. George 5 months ago

        I was wondering the same thing. Where are the chemistry experiment updates?

        Like Dislike
      3. david 5 months ago

        I’m sick of bad football at ND and want it to improve. My fan support is worth more and deserves more than this joke of a product.

        Chanting slogans in a horde of reality-denying lobotomy victims is pathetic. IMO.

        Like Dislike
      4. C-Dog 5 months ago

        David,
        Not sure how old you are, but don’t think for a moment that the rest don’t want Notre Dame competing for and winning national championships.
        By coming on this site and pissing on everyone does not more good than what seems to be making you angry in the first
        Place. It only makes you look like an immature fool and a jackass.
        It also calls into question whether you understand what Notre Dame is about. Why it was formed as a University back in 1843 and why the football team can only win in a manner honoring both the original intent of the University and as a response to the struggles of Irish Catholics in America from the 1850s well into the 20th century.

        If it’s just about a football team the go chear for the Tide. We who are true Notre Dame fans and alums know it’s much more.

        Like Dislike
      5. david 5 months ago

        C-Dog: Read the over-the-top bile that gets posted on these boards after ND loses a game. I don’t recall, but there’s probably some of it posted by you.

        So don’t try to present this “We’re better and more loyal than you” BS. Y’all just have the memories and self-awareness of squirrels.
        And the ND bookstore appreciates it very, very much.

        Like Dislike
      6. C-Dog 5 months ago

        David,
        The difference between the comments made by most of the folks on this board is that they have substance. You’ve just jumped on here recently with personal insulting rants. Most have identified whether they are alums or fans or smongnthe old timers, subway alums. You’ve offered no information to let folks understand where your anger and hatred comes from.
        This is not a trailer trash flame board. The folks here while differing in opinion for the most part have brains and also since most are a bit older have a sense of modicum. Coming in out of the rain with your anger, lack of clarity and lack of purpose really set you up for ridicule.
        Seriously would you walk into a bar for the first time and start screaming personal insults and total strangers? I guess you would if you wanted the bar patrons to turn you into a waffle. But it’s not too intelligent.
        So I ask again can you man up and explain where your anger toward Notre Dame and it’s fans comes from. Why would you be a fan of a team that you seem to also hate and whose fans you seem to wish such I’ll will toward. Your posts spew hate not merely criticism.
        Espn has great boards to spew hate and vent for people whose lives didn’t work out too well. This isn’t that type of site. If you can’t differentiate between critique and hate please just leave us alone.

        Like Dislike
      7. david 5 months ago

        I said it before, and I’ll say it again: No one is forcing you to read my posts. So don’t.
        And instead of being the self-appointed opinion censor, let other, free people make up their own minds to either read or not read them, to agree or to disagree with them.

        If you were really comfortable and secure in your opinions, why do you even care about mine? Do you think you’re protecting little Brian Kelly’s feelings?
        It upsets you that I make valid points. You just can’t admit it, and want to suppress them.

        Like Dislike
      8. david 5 months ago

        And BTW C Dog…whenever you feel an episode of “ND superfan superiority” coming on, recall this little nugget you posted in this very discussion thread: “I (you) don’t see Notre Dame winning another National Championship.”

        What selective hypocrisy directed against me.
        And no wonder you stand up for Brian Kelly. Being a fraud hits close to home.

        Like Dislike
      9. C-Dog 5 months ago

        David,
        I don’t see Notre Dame winning a National Championship. I think it’s too hard in today’s corrupt NCAA environment. It’s too hard to do it and stay Notre Dame. But you are probably too young or too ignorant to understand that.
        And I’m not trying to censor your opinions. I’m just pointing not that this board is for fans who really understand Notre Dame and it’s history. It’s not meant for trolls who really root for other teams. And you come off like a troll from, USC, or Purdue, etc. You sure don’t sound like someone who knows anything about the University.
        And again I never said you shouldn’t be allowed to post. I just pointed out that now most people who see your ID on here know you to be a fool. Possibly some young punk and one who is of that culture that thinks flaming everyone from his keyboard is fine. I’m 51 and I think what you have written here reflects a foolish immature and troubled mind. Go get help David.

        Like Dislike
  12. Ron Burgundy 5 months ago

    Strangest boycott ever, amirite.

    Reply Like Dislike
  13. Bruce Gregory Curme 5 months ago

    Southside et al: See the bottom post on this page. I failed you guys on Duranko ID. Sorry.
    Thanks for clearing it up.

    BGC ’77 ’82

    Reply Like Dislike
    1. duranko 5 months ago

      Bruce, I am at fault here as I ought have clarified this earlier.

      Well, I sort of did but it was about a decade ago.

      I always loved Pete Duranko, and well, when he met Johnny Ray it was like Stanley and Livingstone, Jobs and Wozniak, Gates and Allen, Bogart and Bacall, Leahy and Rockne (one of my favorite things about Frank Leahy, and this has been confirmed by Fred Leahy, is that he shrank from being mentioned in the same breath as Rock). Duranko was probably my favorite ND player, though, in my
      observation, Ross Browner was the best. (I share Southside’s predilection for the defensive side of the ball).

      About a decade ago, somebody challenged me on using the duranko name. Well, I thought that was a more than fair challenge,
      and I put it to a sort of board plebiscite, and the overwhelming consensus, in that particular moment was that the tribute toduranko outweighed either the potential blasphemy or confusion. And, Bruce, I’m being as serious as a heart attack here.

      One more note about Pete Duranko. I LOVE the fact that he was from Johnstown.

      He was both of a favored ethnic nation (Lujack and Hart, surprisingly, were both Polish) and from a sooty industrial town
      that, sort of resonated with my own roots.

      Now as I reread the posts below, you mentioned that your dad, the master, inter alii of standard deviation, outliers, and much, much more, contended that ’66 was the best team he’d seen. I agree with that.

      But Board legend Bob Drake contends, and he was an eyewitness, that ’47 was the best team.

      Even though a fac brat Greg, you know Notre Dame’s principles.

      Bama, as documented by one of the board know-nothings, won the championship.
      But Mekhi Brown’s physical attack on a Alabama staffer.

      That simply would not happened at Notre Dame.

      In ’66, ’73, ’77 and ’88 we won with ND guys, not Mekhi Brown.

      For, after all, what doth it profit a man if he gain the world, or, give or take, a national championship, and lose his soul.

      Notwithstanding, Bruce, and to reset the tone appropriately, I stand by the identity, disturbing or not! of the love child of Fat Eddy and Fat Shirley.

      Go Irish!

      Reply Like Dislike
      1. Bruce Gregory Curme 5 months ago

        It’s good with me, Duranko. It actually seems like you’ve done a pretty good job memorializing PD.
        As for Chunkie Charlie, I think you properly memorialized him as well. (And I think my father would agree with that as well!)

        BGC ’77 ’82

        Like Dislike
      2. C-Dog 5 months ago

        Duranko,
        I have some mixed feelings about the so called honoring. My connections to Notre Dame go both deep,(4 generations) and bros (over 40 extended relatives attended) indeed I have 4 close family memebers who have been employed by the company noversity over the years. A father who helped Leon Hart with his engineering studies. A grandfather who was registrar and was around the University between 1918 and 1940 when he was recalled to active duty. That same grandfather had father Cavaugh give the eulogy at his funeral in 1946.
        We are so ingrained in my family that we talk about things we know are right and things that aren’t at all levels of the University.
        But we don’t often advertise outside the family. And we remain hopeful that in all things the university will live up to its charter. We do not drink the cool aid. We’d like to but we are realistic and critical. We do not hold anyone on a pedestal.
        What I enjoyed as a senior in the 1988 season wasn’t just winning but winning the right way. I don’t beat it over anyone’s head to drink the cool aid. But I also will defend against angry folks like David to understand that the mission is larger than just winning. What do you have to say about Notre Dame’s historic mission. ?

        Like Dislike
      3. duranko 5 months ago

        C dog, I will respond to your post in some degree of detail and be open to agreement, disagreement, refinement, whatever.

        The sticking point is that I’m in the middle of a project right now and it will not be completed until late Saturday.

        But rest assured I will respond, to this message and any follow up.

        Let me say from the beginning, that when it came to ND, I was a, “well,” dreamer. You and your predecessors have the pedigree and the steeping in tradition and its nuance.

        I do not.

        God bless.

        Like Dislike
  14. Damian 5 months ago

    I think C-Dog brings up some interesting points. First, fans have to ask themselves, how far do fans want ND to prostrate themselves to the football gods to be elite. Are academics and a certain discipline culture necessary or do we want ND to sell their sole to the devil? We all know what goes on at some of the power 5 schools, the fake me out majors and courses, the look the other way culture, the “extra” help to meet minimum standards. Do we want to see ND go down that road for a quick fix?

    Now it’s not necessarily either or. ND gets good enough recruits to compete, still, I believe. We lag in the 5 star recruits sometimes because ND won’t take just anyone. I think ND can expand their horizons a bit by taking some on the fence recruits and working a little extra hard with them, the right way that is, to make sure they make the cut.

    I also still believe ND has a coaching issue. BK is not an elite coach. He’s had 8 years to prove it and he’s fallen short. It’s just not there for him. For Cincinatti, Purdue, or any schools like that, they’d be thrilled to have him. He can get you winning seasons, good bowl games for those programs and so forth. But NC’s? No. I think he’s reached as high as he can.

    But if all that’s fixed, we get a really good coach and it still doesn’t work, do I want to see ND take that next step to just being a football factory, or an NFL minor league team? No. I can’t say that I do. Part of the reason I’m an Irish fan is they do stress academics. They expect a certain level of discipline from the players. If they gave that up to be just like the schools down south, I’m not interested. That’s a road I’m not willing to travel. But I don’t think they’re at that point yet. There are still adjustments that can be made. They’ve come close, close enough that it’s still possible for them. That is unless the administrators are satisfied with 9 and 10 win seasons and are satisfied with the status quo, which I fear is what may be the case.

    Reply Like Dislike
    1. Bruce Gregory Curme 5 months ago

      Damian, It was either Duranko or Michael the Archangel who asked the same thing a few sheets ago…”when should we start having the discussion about going down that road just to remain competitive at the very top?” I think you may hear it when BK leaves and before a new head coach is hired. But it’s not up to me, that’s for sure. That will happen on campus behind closed doors…maybe on the 13th Floor or somewhere like that!

      BGC ’77 ’82

      Reply Like Dislike
  15. southside 5 months ago

    BGC , you have South Side blood in you. When did your Dad leave Beverly neighborhood ? My family lived east a few neighborhoods over in St.Joachim’s parish. Where did your Dad attend high school ? My Dad went to DeLaSalle. We all left during the “white flight” to the south suburbs in 1950’s. However , Beverly residents stayed with their roots—and the predominately Irish neighborhood became famous for it’s unique historic houses and the “Castle” on Longwood–resemembling an Irish Castle from the Ould Sod. After moving away –my brothers, friends still attended the St. Patricks South Side Irish parade held in Beverly. This was the real deal –not the St. Patricks parade in downtown Chicago. Beverely was/is still the place where Chicago politicians , Police and Fire dept. employees live.

    Reply Like Dislike
    1. Bruce Gregory Curme 5 months ago

      Dad went to Morgan Park. My grandparents lived on the same side of the street as Givens castle (West), but across the street and down about a block or so in a huge Tudor revival style mansion. My uncle Art (God rest his soul) played chess with the kid of the second (or third) owners of that castle (in the castle)! I always thought that was awesome. Art also was a WWII marine…served as a forward radio operator at Iwo Jima. Dad (and Mom, who is still alive were St. Barnabus people…they met at a church dance there…I was christened there).

      My father never graduated from HS…he dropped out as a junior at 17 to enlist in the Marines in 1943. I don,t know when they moved out of that Tudor, probably when my great grandfather died in the early 50’s…but Mimi Callahan Curme, my grandmother, and Emmitt Gilbert Curme, my uncle and also a WWII marine, wounded at Tarawa, lived the rest of there lives in Beverley.

      BGC ’77 ’82

      Reply Like Dislike
  16. Michael the Archangel 5 months ago

    “Following Elko’s unexpected exit to Texas A&M last week, Lea will become Notre Dame’s next defensive coordinator, according to a report by Yahoo Sports’ Pete Thamel on Tuesday.”
    Stay tuned . . .it might just be a false leaked report . . .if true, got to wonder if that means Elston will be going . . .

    Reply Like Dislike
    1. southside 5 months ago

      MTA , hopefully it’s true. Lea knows the system Elko introduced. A defense that returns numerous players who are already familiar with it. Mike Elston D- Line coach hopefully stays. He and Lea would be great tandem working together for 2018.

      Reply Like Dislike
      1. Bruce Gregory Curme 5 months ago

        Sounds like a plan to me!

        BGC ’77 ’82

        Like Dislike
  17. Bruce Gregory Curme 5 months ago

    C-Dog,
    As I said, I’ll handle David…as soon as I get a chance to get to the University on other matters…I’ve got pneumonia (my wife) and weather issues, but I need to go there for some other business anyway (football lottery email address). This may surprise David, but he is no priority in my life, and neither is the lottery, but I’ll get to it eventually! But it is important to me to defend my statement that some sports generated revenue (not all, for sure) is taxed.

    Texas A&M has more money for everything than we do David…it’s a state run institution with an endless supply of state and federal tax dollars at its disposal. I’ve never heard a more DUMB ASS statement from you than the one below on that!

    David – send me your data on your “80%” statement. You know the one…that you just flat out made up out of thin air. Yeah: that one. We’ve been waiting for it David. JACK ASS.

    PS: There is one thing you’ve got right…tickets are WAY overpriced. And it wasn’t always that way.

    BGC ’77 ’82

    Reply Like Dislike
    1. david 5 months ago

      “This may surprise David, but he is no priority in my life..” yet here you are, allegedly dealing with Pneumonia, posting that.

      Like Donald Trump tweeting he’s a very sane genius.

      Reply Like Dislike
      1. Bruce Gregory Curme 5 months ago

        My wife has pneumonia David…not me.

        BGC ’77 ‘8

        Like Dislike
      2. Notre Dan 5 months ago

        Well Trump is a genius, he whipped the Democrats, broke the media and has you talking about him. The man is good at what he does. He is certainly better than the alternatives from the Democrats. Now stop being butt hurt, snowflake and get back to football.

        Like Dislike
    2. david 5 months ago

      Notre Dan, man of letters: Your post is odd.
      First, your statement that Trump is a genius. This indicates one thing very clearly: you are not.

      And not one word of your post mentions football…..except to tell me to “get back to football!”.

      But thanks for the entertainment…..better than watching an ND football game. (see what I did there?)

      Reply Like Dislike
  18. Joe Libby 5 months ago

    If you look at Elko’s History, his loyalty is
    is totally from the highest salary for Elko.
    If the reports are true, he leveraged the ND
    With Texas A&M, he sets a very poor example of integrity to student athletics he coaches.

    Reply Like Dislike
  19. david 5 months ago

    If Texas A&M, has more money to allocate to its football program than mighty ND does, then ND should be ashamed of itself.

    And you as a fan should be ashamed of ND.

    Reply Like Dislike
    1. C-Dog 5 months ago

      Are you an ND fan or alum?

      Reply Like Dislike
      1. david 5 months ago

        What does that matter?
        My opinion is what it is. Read it or don’t. Agree with it or don’t.

        Like Dislike
      2. C-Dog 5 months ago

        Well David,
        This site is for Alums and Subway Alums ( I assume you know that term from Notre Dame tradition). Trolls are sad sorry folks who generally have been outcast from the sites and places they’d like to join. So they take it out on random groups and spew their anger.
        About 10 years ago we had on this site, a butt hurt dude named Angry Eagle, affectionately know as Anus Eagle to the fold. He came and went. Admitted to being a completely pissed off at life ex army guy. We think he maybe blew his brains out or went to jail for some violent assault. Then there was Robert what’s his name who threatened to sue everyone. Recently we’ve had Ron Burghundy, whom some think is an Ohio State fan, punking the site, while others think it’s actually Frank trying to drum up site hits.
        I’m just wondering why you are taking space with the intense anger like you have something to prove. I do agree that the Irish fans need to be realistic. I was a senior at Notre Dame in 88-89 when they won the last NC. We all knew the team. They attended many of the same classes any one of us did. They lived scattered in the mens’ dorms. They were one of us. It was special. Notre Dame still does that if you didn’t know. So there are several elements to Notre Dame that still make it special. But I agree that Kelly has torn a bit of that down.
        But why the obsession with the whole tax thing? Are you IRS, or were you nailed for tax evasion? You sure have been lit about your opinions. It get’s old dude. This site isn’t about flame wars. It’s for fans and alums. So if you have insightful criticism because you care about ND please start offering it. If you are a troll, well go seek help. I would feel sorry for your life if you are a troll.

        Like Dislike
      3. Ron Burgundy 5 months ago

        It’s “The” Ohio State University.

        Like Dislike
      4. david 5 months ago

        FYI: There’s no password, no credentials, no membership requirement or restriction to this message board.
        Ignore my posts…I’m fine with it.

        Like Dislike
    2. duranko 5 months ago

      Listen you nutcase.

      America allows free speech.

      But your mother and father raised you poorly, very poorly, THEY FAILED, and you failed to rescue yourself.

      You are an emotional midget.

      And, son, if you ever said that to me in a bar after a Notre Dame game, about what I should or not be ashamed of, well,………………………………………………………………….

      You, are not my circus, not my chimpanzee.

      Now, go talk to your shrink and ask her/it/him why you are so screwed up.

      Reply Like Dislike
      1. david 5 months ago

        Posting anonymous threats of physical violence on the internet. Yeah, your parents did a great job and must be very proud.

        And your good Christian education really shines through. Debate club captain?

        Quit with the weird, mutual admiration society stroll down memory lane, and try making a point about ND football.
        I dare you.

        Like Dislike
  20. Bruce Gregory Curme 5 months ago

    To respond to Damian and someone else about two days ago, I’d say the three most important things for the new DC would be 1. an ability to inspire men before and during the season…get them to work and believe (in themselves) as well as their coaches)…and 2. Must be able to teach it at every level…fundamentals to on-field recognition and everything in between…and teach his own assistants as well…and 3. Able to put the correct pegs in the right holes…line ’em up right!

    These things, as the other poster said, are probably more important than any particular scheme.

    Also to Paddy and a few others – Kelly is no fraud but he also is not a “great” coach like Rockne or Leahy, or Ara , or Lou. He ranks a bit like Layden or Brennan (both good coaches), or some might say Devine (though I think DD was a great coach personally and underrated at ND).

    BGC
    La Crosse, Indiana

    Reply Like Dislike
    1. david 5 months ago

      You’re a fraud, claiming college football is not tax exempt.
      But continue with your public love notes if you like.

      Reply Like Dislike
    2. Paddy Irish 5 months ago

      Never said Kelly was a fraud, said he was average

      Reply Like Dislike
      1. Bruce Gregory Curme 5 months ago

        Paddy, Bad wording on my part…I did not mean that you said he was a fraud…I was using you as an example of someone who specifically did not say that…said he was a good coach. Bad wording, totally my fault.

        BGC ’77 ’82

        Like Dislike
    3. Paddy Irish 5 months ago

      Layden’s 1935 and 1938 and Brennans 1954 are good comparisons to kellys 2012, only prob, which isnt kellys fault is those two prior coaches did not follow almost 20yrs of mostly bad seasons.

      Reply Like Dislike
    4. duranko 5 months ago

      Well, that is whole ‘nother kettle of fish.

      I feel that Devine was vastly undervalued as an ND coach, mostly because he simply did not “give good podium.”

      This was in stark contradistinction to Ara Raoul his own self.

      Devine reminds me of my high school coach who would not let us take our helmets off because “don’t let ’em see what you look like.”

      Devine also lacked political savvy and did his best to annoy people.

      NEVERTHELESS, he was some kind of coach.

      ’77? Loss to Ole Miss or not, this was a great ND champion. From the day they beat Army in the Meadowlands, after a week off, they were one of ND’s great teams, only slowing down when the Zebras tried to stampede the Irish in Clemson’s Death Valley (what ND fan can forget the 120 yard drive!) Texas? Hah! Heisman Trophy Winner Campbell and never to be heard from again Outland winner Brad Shearer after he got HUGHESED by big Ernie, and we made SPAM out of Lam, Jam, and Ham. 38-10. Hah it wasn’t that close as the Horns got their only TD at end of first half with time experienced after an interference penalty.

      ’78? Normally I accept bad refereeing as part of the turbulence of the game. But the non-fumble call against USC was a
      complete screwing.

      ’80 Wow, he negotiated a tricky QB situation and was in the race until November.
      And for reasons relating to Hesburgh and the whole civil rights issue, beating Bama in the Belly of the Beast at Legion Field in Birmingham 7-0 was probably my most enjoyable ND win EVER.

      He had five of ND’s greatest victories

      USC ’77
      Texas ’77 NC
      Houston ’78 Cotton Bowl
      Michigan ’80
      Bama ’80

      Danny, Boy, we hardly knew ye…..

      Reply Like Dislike
      1. Paddy Irish 5 months ago

        Harry-o’s kick was my first game…Go Irish!

        Like Dislike
      2. duranko 5 months ago

        Paddy, that was a pretty good first game.

        What was so strange is that Bo and Devine were pretty straitlaced football coaches. Limit penalties and turnovers and block downfield and pursue
        the ball carrier. FUNDAMENTALS.

        Not that day, As you remember it was wild and wooly. I had an odd angle of Harry’s kick and was confident it would miss and then it seemed to hit an air current.

        Go Irish!

        Like Dislike
  21. Damian 5 months ago

    Ok, maybe ND wasn’t necessarily outbid, and it appears Elko has other concerns about ND. I’m not going to get into whether it makes him a bad guy or not. He clearly didn’t have any particular loyalty to ND. As far as I know he had no ties to the Irish. So be it.

    But I am still concerned that ND now appears to be a stepping stone and not a destination. That we get coaches that are looking for better and brighter things, in the same position. That is the concern. If you lose a good assistant to a HC job, ok, that could even be a good thing if they’re successful in their new HC gig. But we’re losing guys to lateral jobs. That tells me ND is clearly not in the pinnacle of coaching jobs anymore.

    I’m not sure who ND turns to next. As Greg noted their are other DC candidates out there. I’m not sure who’s on the market right now though. But who they get will be key. Do we get someone that builds on what Elko did and coaches a similar scheme and can just pick up where he left off? Or is it someone that will require ND to retool their defense and basically start from scratch?

    Reply Like Dislike
    1. southside 5 months ago

      Damian , what’s wrong with a new hired DC , OC or any other coach using ND for a spring board. No such thing as “final destination” in any sport that I know of —college or pro.

      Reply Like Dislike
      1. Bruce Gregory Curme 5 months ago

        Yeah, and the revolving door at “D” coordinator started during the Holtz era anyway…a long time ago. These men need and deserve space to grow…but after one year?…and after we met their first offer? No bidding war – he’s good, but he isn’t that good!

        BGC ’77 ’82

        Like Dislike
  22. ndcrazymike 5 months ago

    ND lost a DEF. COORDINATOR not the greatest assistant coach ever!!! ELKO left for $$$$ and only $$$$! He felt NO LOYALTY to ND even after they gave him the biggest contract for a assistant coach!!! ELKO was a good coach did a great job, but is he the only DEF. COORDINATOR there is? U guys jump ship every 5 minutes!! EVERYTHING AT ND IS BASED ON FAITH!! With a 10 win season and a hell of a recruiting class on the way the team is headed in the right direction!! ELKO,S GONE GET OVER IT! Don’t let DAVEY DOWNER drag u down!!!

    Reply Like Dislike
    1. david 5 months ago

      ARGGGHHHH…..MY PILLS!

      Reply Like Dislike
  23. SteelFanRob 6 months ago

    Bama is in the winning NC buisness….

    ND is in the marketing nostalgia business….

    Reply Like Dislike
    1. C-Dog 6 months ago

      I don’t see Notre Dame winning another National Championship. Sadly they’ve spent over 1/2 billion on a monument that will never fulfill its intent. The stadium was fine for a future Ivy League wannabe. Imagine the scholarship fund that money could have incubated. Imagine the aid to the poor making the “What would you fight for” marketing more real.
      FBS Football is for the South.. Let those dummies wear the uniform and win for the rich elite. Let the slobs root for their team like it’s the civil war all over again. Put a few in the NFL and let the rest remember the glory they gave the Tide or the Tigers or the Dawgs when they are pushing a broom.

      No, Notre Dame, it’s time to go FCS and Ivy League and promote your upper class suburban white collar sports.

      Rent out the stadium for FBS games. The winner can pretend they beat Notre Dame instead of their actual foe. In fact Let a Power 5 play a lower ranked Group of 5 school and let the Group of 5 rent the Notre Dame uniforms. Then everyone will be happy. And Notre Dame will get Rich. Of course 1/20 if the proceeds will go to a marketing firm to remind everyone that Notre Dame has something to do with some guy named Jesus…….and his Mother

      Reply Like Dislike
      1. david 5 months ago

        So…you can lash out with a childish, thin-skinned attack on all the competitive schools/teams in college football, but you want to censor my far more objectively accurate complaints about the state of ND football under Kelly.

        You self-righteous, brazen hypocrite.

        Like Dislike
  24. SteelFanRob 6 months ago

    What a pleasure to see such QB play from true freshmen!

    Saban is a genius. He and Bill Belichick are once in a generation coaches!

    Nothing can be done about their greatness!

    Reply Like Dislike
  25. Ryan 6 months ago

    If Lea takes off we are in for a world of hurt imo. He is the only one that can keep our defensive system, that did prove better, and continue its growth.

    Reply Like Dislike
    1. david 6 months ago

      To me, this would help things along. The solid defensive staff propped up Kelly’s incompetent arse.
      And NDs record this year made fans like y’all forget (or at least deny) that Kelly is a fraud.

      The sooner Kelly’s gone, however it happens, the sooner ND can get a real coach.
      And if they won’t pay for a proven one, and can’t find some junior miracle hire, then they’ll keep pretending to play Big Boy football but charge fans as if they do.

      Reply Like Dislike
      1. Paddy Irish 5 months ago

        This is my biggest fear about the next head coach (whenever it comes) is we have the same jerks at the university who dont think winning championships is the most important factor. Money and monuments and playing off the back of the great deeds of the past are more important than adding new glorious chapters. So, when Kelly is gone one day will we get the next Lou or Ara? Or, do we get the next Davie or Faust and restart the crap cycle. I think it would be more likely we could get an era worse than Kelly, since the coaching hires the last nearly 40 yrs dont really inspire the football world. Since 1981 we have had Faust, Lou, Davie, Ty, Chuckie Cheeseburger, and Kelly. Kelly is number two on that list and more successful by a longshot of the ones behind him, I find that scary. I understand your dislike for Kelly completely, half the games he has lost are from his inability to realize that all games cannot be treated the same way, but at the same time I am not in a hurry to fire him (outside another 2016 season) because 8-10 win seasons and bowl wins are better than losing seasons, but are still salt in the wound, because there is no reason we cant be a real contender for the playoff most seasons.

        Like Dislike
      2. Paddy Irish 5 months ago

        Plus, Kelly isnt a fraud, he is an average coach. You are right he doesnt belong here. His 8.5 wins a season would be great for Purdue, but is garbage at ND.

        Like Dislike
      3. david 5 months ago

        Paddy: “If we get rid of this guy, we might end up with worse.”

        A lot of people here think exactly that. You have become so despondent and used to disappointment that the status quo is better than taking a chance. Because the conditioning you’ve received as a ND fan for the past 25 years is that it is more likely that change will make things worse, not better.
        Quite rational mindset….reflecting the pathetic, sad state of ND football.

        Scared of the future. Giving up any hope of excellence. Afraid of risk. Mediocre is good enough.
        From ND admins. perspective, mediocre football is acceptable. Boatloads of money will still come in….there’s many, many years of proof of that.

        But as a fan, the whole point of following a team is to be hopeful. The opposite of hopeless.
        For me, ND football under Brian Kelly is hopeless. So I don’t watch it anymore.

        Like Dislike
      4. Paddy Irish 5 months ago

        I am frustrated and disappointed with ND, and I do not have much faith the admin to make the moves to make this program what it should be. I agree with most of what you say. It has been nearly 25 years of mostly crap football. But, I don’t think Kelly is the main problem, I think it is the behind the scenes actions that brought us Kelly is the real problem. So, yes I lack confidence for the futre head coach. But, even with Kelly as head coach I will watch and cheer my Irish and hope that under him they win their way back to excellence. If they don’t I will cheer on the next coach. N o matter great or bad they do I will root them on, it would just be a lot easier if they were the Irish of old.

        Like Dislike
      5. david 5 months ago

        Kelly has shown no ability to hire good staff OR to keep them around for awhile. Recruiting is objectively slipping, a problem compounded by the thin depth chart suffering early departures every year.
        Meanwhile, opens the wallet for a great staff. And TA&M doesn’t have NBC money to play with…

        ND just doesn’t care enough about championship football to try to find another coach. They’re content with BSer Kelly.

        Like Dislike
  26. C-Dog 6 months ago

    It gets better folks. Word is Elko is taking Polian and Clark Lea with him. Lovely!! I’m betting Kelly is talking to the NFL right now. If he doesn’t figure it out within the next week or two, he’s going to be faced with 2014-2016 all over again. 7-5 going into the bowl next year. But hey, Duranko, ( not the real Pete Duranko but a delusional fake Duranko), will make sure everyone keeps the faith, or else.

    2022 is the year Notre Dame breaks through. I’ll just be happy to see Mike Brey over achieve finally, and Muffet could collect a couple of National Championships in that time. The Hockey team is ranked #1 right now and might get a championship. The mens and womens soccer teams compete very well. And one year not to far from now, the Lacrosse team is going to not only get to the final but will win it all.

    Reply Like Dislike
    1. ndcrazymike 5 months ago

      YES THE SKY IS FALLING THE SKY IS FALLING!! AND THE GOLDEN DOME IS LEAVING!!

      Reply Like Dislike
  27. C-Dog 6 months ago

    Framing the argument to justify or vilify Notre Dame or Elko is both useless and immature.

    The real issue is a reflection of college football and poses two questions: 1. Can Notre Dame continue to be Notre Dame and compete in the near term? 2. Is the trending state of FBS football sustainable?

    I say No to both those questions. If things continue, Notre Dame can either maintain it’s integrity or it can cave, otherwise it’s not going to be able to sustain highly ranked teams.

    The seeds of today’s FBS corruption stem from the 1950s when the southern and southwestern schools started to gain prominence. The playing field for the time was even until the 1980s when Jimmy Johnson institutionalized ghetto culture in college football. During the 1980s the NCAA made an attempt to crack down and clean up corruption among programs and conferences. And there was a balance as several prominent schools were among the independents to push back against the conferences. But indeed ghetto football sold and by the 1990s everyone accepted that there didn’t need to be a student in student athletes.
    Today, the Power 5 conferences and ESPN have monopolized the sport such that the NCAA has little effect other than making token examples. And we’re finding that a program such as Penn State or USC coming off sanctions are darlings among those power brokers. Crime may not pay but it sure sells. The good Fathers at Notre Dame in Rockne’s time did not want a football factory. Well, consider how a school can compete for coaching continuity with the bids going up dynamically. Consider how a program can put real academic responsibility on a kid and develop a top notch athlete to the level required. The Soviets and the East Germans would envy the strength and conditioning and enhanced substance use by the average top college athlete. While this continues and increases, Notre Dame cannot be that Old Notre Dame and still compete. Stanford is barely sustaining it, just barely. You can have a Notre Dame program at the top, but you probably have a team that’s like the rest. Not my Notre Dame anymore. I hope it never turns out that way.

    But two answer question 2, is the current trend sustainable? No way. There’s either going to be a lawsuit against the Power 5, a successful lawsuit by the players, (taking the Northwestern precedent one step further), or economics will cause a collapse. The NFL hurting in the ratings. College football could be next. It certainly won’t be across the board, but you could see a drop off in ratings for games not among top 10 ranked schools. And if the southeast dominates, well folks in other regions might find something else to do with their time. The Pac-12 is struggling to keep fan interest and the weird game times reflect that. And who bothered to watch the bowls not on New Year’s weekend. I didn’t even watch the playoffs except to tune in for about 10 minutes each game just to check the score. I checked the bowls that Florida State was in and the also West Virginia to see that each game had a lot of empty seats in the stands. Betting ratings sucked for those too.

    With sports diverging into white collar sports and blue collar sports, the greed of the Power 5, ESPN, and the NCAA itself may cause a collapse in FBS football. I can’t wait because it’s after that event that Notre Dame can shine again. May we be the beacon of light for the post FBS future.

    Reply Like Dislike
    1. david 6 months ago

      ND’s has no more “integrity” than any other university athletic dept.
      It’s just a big business linked to an entity that classifies its profit tax-free.

      What it IS is cheap….cannily using its “mystique” built up more than a generation ago to keep its revenue up and its costs down.
      It is just monetizing nostalgia. On the cheap.
      Ding ding ding.

      Reply Like Dislike
      1. ndcrazymike 5 months ago

        YOU R SO ANGRY DAVE! WHATS A MATTER DAVEY, HOLD YOUR BREATH AND JUMP UP AND DOWN!! SCREAM I HATE U BRIAN KELLY, YOU R A FN DOPE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

        Like Dislike
    2. Gmoney321 5 months ago

      A few things you have failed to address. The college football field was not level until the institution of the scholarship limitations.
      In addition, if it wasn’t for the messed up bowl and conference alignments, Notre Dame would not have had a shot at Texas in 1977.
      I agree with you on the institutionalized ghetto culture, but Jimmie Johnson was the first person to win regularly with it, not the first
      to use it. If you think there wasn’t a student denied admission to Notre Dame with better academic and social credentials than some
      on the football team, you are sorely mistaken.
      Lastly, why did college football money explode? You may want to take a look at the timing of Title IX and the explosive growth of money
      in college football and men’s basketball.

      Reply Like Dislike
      1. Bruce Gregory Curme 5 months ago

        Sure Gmoney321,
        Commissioners and AD’s of MOST football schools are scared to death that paying the athletes is next because most of them can’t afford to do it! They don’t sell out their seats in their 50000 seat stadiums. They only get their split of bowl/TV money, pretty small. Presumably, the NCAA would fix the “stipend” amount so the big schools don’t just get in bidding wars for HS juniors, but that isn’t going to help most ADs who already are ever screwed by Title 9! Only a centralized NCAA fund would work (that I can see)…paid for by TV and/or NCAA “tax” money on gates and parking. The fund would dole out the same amount to each athlete, but the big schools would be paying way more into it than anyone else. I smell some CONTREVERSY there.

        BGC ’77 ’82

        Like Dislike
    3. Jack 5 months ago

      C-Dog,

      The real issue is the Conferences run the NCAA and they won’t let their Blue Bloods get punished. Look at UNC basketball, need I say more

      The big problem is you have Southern State Schools breaking the bank for College football because it is the only thing keeping them going. Unlike the 80s most payments are going in cash the the players who are hiding the fact they are getting paid. What will happen with College football is the same thing that happened to AAU basketball, the feds will get involved and blow it up. Problem is I don’t see anyone caring. They almost had it when they busted Miami with Nevin Schapiro, but the NCAA botched it.

      Reply Like Dislike
  28. david 6 months ago

    Brian Kelly interviewed for an NFL job in January of 2012, following his third season of a 5-year contract at ND.
    Eight months later, in August, he brazenly parlayed his (temporary, utterly fluky) leverage into a 5-yr contract extension at ND.

    So it would appear that Notre Dame is can live with and “get over” being abused, blackmailed or coerced when it gets what it wants.

    But when it gets it gets straight up embarrassed, being outbid because they’re cheap…..it tries to present itself as being “above such sordidness, such insincerity”.
    I’m sure they poured on the full-bore “Gipper, tradition, family” shtick as price lowering incnetive. And I’m glad Elko didn’t fall for it.

    But you keep buying overpriced tickets for disappointing entertainment. And keep rationalizing how it warms your soul.

    Reply Like Dislike
    1. ndcrazymike 5 months ago

      Same old same old DAVEY!! What a dope same complaints same crying! Why haven’t u complained about LEA I’m sure u can tell us how bad a move that was DAVEY! Take your G.E.D education to a different site, your knowledge of football is only exceeded by your stupidity on all issues!!

      Reply Like Dislike
  29. Greg Kelly 6 months ago

    For a minute there, thought Elko would be conscripted to A& M posse.

    Reply Like Dislike
  30. ChrisJ 6 months ago

    Duranko’s curb stomping of Elko in a previous post was perfect and this article just proves how completely correct Duranko was!!!

    Reply Like Dislike
    1. Bruce Gregory Curme 6 months ago

      And trust me on this: That was the real Pete Duranko – he knew some things no delusional phony ever could have known.

      BGC ’77 ’82

      Reply Like Dislike
      1. Bruce Gregory Curme 6 months ago

        PS Duranko: When I told you that my “dear old dad” always said the ’66 team was the best ND team he ever saw, I hope you realize he saw all the Leahy teams as well! (Except one, he missed one “vacationing” in beautiful Guam and Saipan with the 2nd and 3rd Marines). He grew up on Longwood Drive in Beverley in Chicago, and followed the Irish. So I was always impressed by that…you should be too.

        BGC ’77 ’82

        Like Dislike
      2. southside 5 months ago

        BGC , you are aware that Pete Duranko , Notre Dame football player for the ’66 team passed away a few years ago.

        Like Dislike
      3. Bruce Gregory Curme 5 months ago

        No Southside. I was obviously deceived by someone who knew the era, was around Duranko, knew my father, took his stats class, and knew other things as well, or had a close source with himto draw on. Sorry, I failed you guys. Thanks for clearing it up.

        He never said he was Pete Duranko, I said that. He is certainly somebody who was ND educated though.

        Like Dislike