| Player | Pos | No. | Years |
|---|---|---|---|
| Kyle Brindza | PK | 27 | 2012–2014 |
| Josh Bryan | PK | 91 | 2021 |
| Noah Burnette | PK | 98 | 2025 |
| Marcello Diomede | PK | 48 | 2023–2025 |
| Jonathan Doerer | PK | 39 | 2018–2021 |
| Dawson Goepferich | PK | 38 | 2020 |
| Eric Goins | PK | 90 | 2024 |
| Blake Grupe | PK | 99 | 2022 |
| Mitch Jeter | PK | 98 | 2024 |
| Harrison Leonard | PK | 36 | 2019–2021 |
| David Ruffer | PK | 97 | 2008–2011 |
| Chris Salerno | PK | 26 | 2024 |
| Erik Schmidt | PK | 18 | 2025 |
| Spencer Shrader | PK | 32 | 2023 |
| Nick Tausch | PK | 40 | 2009–2013 |
| Brandon Walker | PK | 96 | 2007–2008 |
| Nate Whitaker | PK | 39 | 2007 |
| Zac Yoakam | PK | 96 | 2023–2024 |
| Justin Yoon | PK | 19 | 2015–2018 |
| Jay Bramblett | P | 19 | 2019–2021 |
| Mike Grieco | P | 37 | 2011 |
| Ben Krimm | P | 43 | 2023 |
| Eric Maust | P | 43 | 2007–2009 |
| Bryce McFerson | P | 34 | 2023 |
| Tyler Newsome | P | 85 | 2015–2018 |
| James Rendell | P | 16 | 2024–2025 |
| Jeff Riney | P | 42 | 2017 |
| Jon Sot | P | 39 | 2022 |
| Ben Turk | P | 35 | 2009–2012 |
| Alex Wulfeck | P | 98 | 2013 |
| Jordan Cowart | LS | 60 | — |
| Scott Daly | LS | 61 | 2016 |
| Andrew Kros | LS | 49 | 2024 |
| Rino Monteforte | LS | 39 | — |
| Alex Peitsch | LS | 44 | — |
| John Shannon | LS | 54 | 2017–2019 |
| Joseph Vinci | LS | 96 | 2024–2025 |
| Michael Vinson | LS | 65 | 2020–2023 |
