Notre Dame Football On Verge of Doing Something it Hasn’t Done in 23 Years

Photo: Matt Cashore // USA TODAY Sports
Photo: Matt Cashore // USA TODAY Sports

It will have been 247 days and approximately 5,928 hours since Notre Dame last took the field by the time the Fighting Irish square off against the Texas Longhorns this upcoming Sunday  (but who’s counting?) in Austin, and there are countless storylines that will occupy Irish fans this week until zero hour.  Will DeShone Kizer or Malik Zaire emerge as the starting quarterback?  Can Notre Dame overcome the loss of Max Redfield at safety?  How will defensive coordinator Brian VanGorder create an effective pass rush, or does Notre Dame simply lack the weaponry to do so?  While relevant, all of these questions are secondary to the larger question that holds the key to the future: will Notre Dame finally post back-to-back seasons with double digit victories?

How many Notre Dame fans realize 23 years have passed since South Bend has been home to back-to-back 10+ win seasons?  Legendary coach Lou Holtz accomplished the feat twice between the 1992 and 1993 seasons as well as the 1988 and 1989 seasons, but prior to the Holtz era it hadn’t been accomplished since Ara Parseghian during the 1972 and 1973 seasons.  In fact, Notre Dame has only posted back-to-back 10+ win seasons three times in the past 44 years, and Lou Holtz is the only head coach in program history to record three seasons In a row with double digit victories (although, in defense of past Notre Dame coaches, only nine to ten games were played per year in the Knute Rockne era).  But think about those numbers and compare them to the seasons two of Notre Dame’s traditional opponents have had in recent years.

Mark Dantonio accepted the head coaching job in East Lansing in 2007.  During his tenure as Michigan State’s head coach Dantonio has won at least 11 games in five of the past six seasons and is currently riding a streak of three seasons in a row of 11+ wins.  Since 2013 Dantonio has managed to accomplish a feat Notre Dame has only succeeded in doing once in its 129 year history.  And it’s because of Michigan State’s torrent of winning that the Spartans are currently knocking on the door of being a top ten ranked team again in 2016 despite:

  • Losing all-time passing and touchdown leader, Connor Cook, at quarterback
  • Losing two of its best offensive linemen in Jack Conklin and Jack Allen
  • Losing 50-percent of last season’s passing production in wide receivers Aaron Burbridge and MacGarrett Kings
  • Losing all defensive line starters save one as well as losing nearly all backup defensive linemen
  • Being forced to rely upon true freshmen at defensive line

Underscoring the point is the fact one of the true freshmen Dantonio will likely rely upon, Auston Robertson, was a recruit Dantonio gained by pulling the rug out from underneath Notre Dame.  Robertson, a 4-star defensive end from Fort Wayne, Ind., with offers from the likes of Michigan and Ohio State, is the kind of must-have prospect Notre Dame needs to bring in on an annual basis from within the confines of its non-fertile recruiting base of Indiana.  But winning begets winning, and there have been few programs that have done it as consistently well as the Spartans in recent years, creating a lure to East Lansing that makes life more difficult for Notre Dame.

A similar story can be told with Stanford.  David Shaw took over in Palo Alto in 2011 and in his five seasons as head coach he’s won 11+ games four times.  When you add in Jim Harbaugh’s 12-1 record in his final season as Cardinals head coach in 2010, Stanford had four consecutive seasons of double digit victories between 2010 and 2013, something Notre Dame has never accomplished in all of its storied history.  And that continued success plays a large role in losing key talent to Stanford, such as 4-star wide receiver Osiris St. Brown whose brother plays for Notre Dame and whose father has gone on record stating he would like the brothers to be teammates at the collegiate level.

This fall will be the fourth time since Lou Holtz’s departure in 1996 that Notre Dame will be coming off a 10+ win season.  In 2003 Tyrone Willingham followed up the previous year’s 10-win season with a 5-7 performance.  In 2007, Notre Dame went 3-9 under Charlie Weis after a 10-3 season in 2006.  And most recently, Brian Kelly posted a 9-4 record in 2013 after leading Notre Dame to an undefeated regular season in 2012.  This fall represents an opportunity for Notre Dame to take a large step forward in its quest to become a truly elite program, and as outlined last week, the stars have aligned themselves within Notre Dame’s schedule to make that step a real possibility.  But it’s an opportunity Notre Dame can ill-afford to waste.

Scott Janssen is a blogger for The Huffington Post and has authored several nationally-featured articles, including an appearance on MSNBC as a sports contributor.  He talks football 24 hours a day, much to the chagrin of his wife and those around him.  Scott can be reached at or follow him on Twitter.

You may also like


  1. Good article. Facts are facts. Granted, those schools will never compete with ND on a recognition level, but right now, MSU and Stanford are better football programs. The Irish are losing a lot of talent to Stanford because of it (they compete with the Irish on every level including academics). Only one way to get it back: beat them on the field, which they will. Go Irish!

  2. Scott, did you graduate from Moo U? How can you possibly compare MSU, that is not even in the top 70% of schedule power rankings to ND Top Ten power rankings every year? Dantonio has scheduled all MAC teams the last 10 years outside the weak ten conference games. Nice hatchet job on the success under Kelly, try comparing MSU to Eastern Michigan, Kent State and then lets talk!

  3. Shazamrock – Good, accurate stats.

    MSU don’t care at all – they will be loaded for bear.

    MSU is MSU, and they couldn’t care less about our stats, our tradition, our graduation rate, or anything – they just want to kick our ass, and they will come ready to do so.

    Personally I would love to see that game on the dirt, in the rain, with uniform numbers blotted out by mud and blood, and fought down to the last second with N.D. kicking a field goal with 3 seconds left to win 23-21.

    Just win, baby – just win.

  4. In 128 seasons, ND boasts a .734 winning percentage. Best among all D-1 schools.
    228 wins. Best among active head coaches.
    A 93% graduation rate.
    And a fan base that one day will receive total consciousness.(Gunga, galunga)

    So we got that going for us…. which is nice.

  5. It’s probably more accurate to compare ND’s record to other programs, as noted later in the article, then compared to previous coaches because as others have noted, there are more regular season games now.

    ND has a shot at another 10 win season this year. I think from the offensive side, scoring points should not be a problem. Sure, there are some questions as to what receivers will stand out, how the running backs will do, and how the dual QB system plays out, but I think ND will score points. They have also shown some improvement finally on special teams. It’s still a work in progress, but they are at least capable of good punt/kick returns.

    Defense will be the question. I think this will be a make or break year for BVG. There has to be some improvement on defense. I don’t believe it needs to be an elite defense necessarily. Just improved play and discipline. If the defense just does it’s job as a middle of the road defense a 10 win season is very much in the cards.

  6. I think the article shows some good insight, especially about the more recent successes of Stanford and Michigan State. It puts Notre Dame’s recent history in better perspective and shows how pedestrian we have actually become. Not sure what to say since our recruiting talent seems to be pretty good, but our results sure don’t seem to match. Is our schedule really that much tougher than all those other teams that regularly win 10 games? Stanford plays a tough Pac 12 schedule, and us, every year. SEC teams have a few cupcakes to be sure, but also 4- 5 very tough games per year. Time to get over the hurdle.

  7. Looking back over the record, I find that your stats don’t compare apples to apples. First, one inaccuracy: in 1972, Ara was 8-3, incuding a bowl game. Next, Charlie Weis is the first ND coach who played a 12-game season every year in his career. The first 11-game regular season in ND history was Ara’s last, in 1974. Now you could perhaps say that Ara was part of the “Knute Rockne era,” but I wouldn’t agree with you. Holtz had the first 12-game season in 1989, and one other in 1991.

    Your article makes a point, which is that MSU and Stanford have put together programs that win a good deal more often than Notre Dame in the last 10 years. It’s kind of a shame that you’ve dressed up your content with misleading statistics (e.g. “Since 2013 Dantonio has managed to accomplish a feat Notre Dame has only succeeded in doing once in its 129 year history.”).

  8. It’s a heck of a lot easier to win 11 games when:
    1) Your schedule includes Jacksonville State or Furman.
    2) You don’t have a national schedule that regularly forces you to travel across the country.
    3) Your toughest regular opponent outside of UM or OSU is a very down Penn State or Nebraska.

  9. Not sure why you point out that ND only played 9-10 games per year, but then go back to the absence of winning 10 games per year “in all of its storied history” and “once in its 129 year history”. So, you are complaining about the 9-0 years? Exactly how many 10 victory seasons did you expect in the 60 or so years that they didn’t play ten games? Strange article.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button