Duranko’s Digest: What did we see against BYU?

theo riddick byu 2012
Oct. 20, 2012; South Bend, IN, USA; Notre Dame Fighting Irish running back Theo Riddick (6) runs the ball as BYU Cougars linebacker Kyle Van Noy (3) pursues in the third quarter at Notre Dame Stadium. Notre Dame won 17-14. Mandatory Credit: Matt Cashore-US PRESSWIRE

The Fighting Irish moved to 7-0 by defeating two opponents.  The first was a game Cougars team, going all out for a signature win.  The second, more daunting opponent was the physical and mental hangover from the OT win against Stanford.

While Ev Golson, smiling on the sideline, did not participate, Tommy Rees handled business to guide the Irish to victory.  He simultaneously demonstrated why, despite his remarkable competence as a reliever, he doesn’t measure up as the ND starting quarterback. Rees passed early to Eifert, forcing the Cougars to cover Tyler more closely, which provided a fulcrum for the Irish rushing attack, which gashed BYU’s defense for quadruple their customary rushing yardage yield.

At the 6:31 mark of the third quarter the Cougars missed a field goal, giving the ball to the Irish who trailed 14-7.  In their next three possessions, the Irish  generated 65 yards in 7, 72 yards in 8 plays, and a suffocating, clock-chewing 48 yards in 9 plays.  And the Irish were then ahead, for good, 17-14.

The Notre Dame defense, having gone 17 quarters without yielding a touchdown, gave up two passing TDS in the middle of the second quarter.  That was it. They began a new two quarter no TD streak in the second half, and have now played 7 games, 28 quarters, 420 minutes without allowing a rushing TD.

This 2012 Notre Dame team channels Rooster Cogburn. They have shown true grit in four 4th quarters, protecting leads against Purdue and Michigan, and coming from behind against Stanford and the Cougars. Make no mistake, this toughness is a habit, a trait, not mere luck.

Player of the Game: Theo Riddick. Many internet cognoscenti were certain that Wood was the better rusher.  Theo said no. He had two archival runs. The first was in the second quarter, a Reggie Brooks/Ray Zellars/Irv Smith-evoking, tackle breaking burst through the left side for 27 yards.  The other gem was the “I ain’t down” show of focus for 55 yards late in the 3rd quarter.

With the final margin at 17-14, the Irish left the field 7-0 and bowl eligible. I think we have another game next Saturday.


We add one feature to this week’s unit rankings.  We identify a “pivot player” whose performance,if improved, can elevate the performance of his unit. Admittedly, this is more conjectural than evidentiary, but let’s try it..  We’ll use “Keep an Eye on” but that will identify the “pivot player.”


Front seven-consistent excellence. Excellence from the starters, quality depth, play with good, clean violence without stupid roughness penalties and have no apparent weakness.  Keep an Eye on:

Ishaq Williams-has playmaking ability but Shembo is playing so well it’s tough to get snaps.  Nevertheless Diaco and Ishaq must collaborate to get him on the field.  He’s ready to be a difference maker right now.

TES-they catch passes. Eifert is America’s best receiving TE. They block like madmen (especially #85 other than his mulligan against Stanford-he’s a great run blocker, just learning as a pass blocker) and can get downfield when needed.

Keep an Eye on: Koyack-if he can elevate his play just a little bit, then Kelly can feel safer in using the three TE formation.

RBS-yes, they have EARNED the promotion to BCS level. This is a competent, mature group, and they now block better than they have in the past. And yes, we are counting Theo Riddick in both the WR and RB group.

Keep an Eye on: George Atkinson III, has progressed steadily, but if he can become even a minor pass catching threat, the offense opens up.  Can you just envision him in space with a linebacker in front of him? He also could use ten more pounds of muscle on his upper body.

New Year’s Day Bowl Level

OL-Purdue is now officially a mulligan.  As Golson and the passing game progress, the run opportunities open up. Keep in mind, that in October we have, in three games, rushed for 796 yards, or 265 per game.  That pace would rank 8th in America in rushing offense. The left side is great, the right side OK.  Biggest remaining tests are OU and SC.

Keep an Eye on: Chris Lombard, if he can solidify his play, the right side can close the gap with the left side.

Bowl level

QBS-Golson has exceeded expectations. He continues to excel in the short to intermediate passing game, and is improving as a runner.  His command of the offense, the huddle and the field are getting better. Psst!! Everett: ball security, Ball Security, BALL SECURITY!! A “good” outing against OU, whatever that means, could earn a bump in grade.

Keep an Eye on: Tommy Rees – doesn’t it feel as if he has one more relief stint in him?  Oh, and have you noticed a tall blond kid on the sideline, that kid from Columbus, Indiana.  Well, he won’t play this year, but nothing he’s seen on the field scares him.

WRS – steadily improving, but not daunting. The youngsters are progressing, but they need to take another step up.  They really don’t drop balls. T.J. Jones has now arrived as a playmaker.  He’s not a gamebreaker, but he comes up big in the clutch.

Keep an eye on: Chris Brown-if he can catch just one bomb, it will change him and the disrupt the peace of mind of opposing coordinators.

DBS-have played better than expected for three first year (and two surprise) starters.  They are athletic and play physically enough.  The three biggest tests (OU, SC and bowl opponent) are yet to come.  They are a pleasantly surprising 8th in the nation in pass efficiency defense.  Keep an Eye on:Matthias Farley and Elijah Shumate.  Farley survived and advanced against Stanford, but  he has more tests to pass.  Shumate is getting more comfortable, and if the coaches can get comfortable lining him up against WRS of OU and SC, that’s a great leap forward.  This unit is still the Achilles heel.


This is an unusually unified football team, even by Notre Dame standards. They trust each other, they lift each other up, they are fond of each other, they are accountable to each other in addition to the uniform, the fans and the coaches. Great parts, for sure, but the whole is greater than the sum of the parts.  The most unified team, top to bottom, since 1993.


Did you hear the one about the two bookends that Notre Dame built in Norman?

In 1953, Bud Wilkinson, a product of Bernie Bierman’s wondrous machine at Minnesota, was in his seventh year as OU head coach. He had coached Billy Vessels to the Heisman  in 1952.

The incomparable Frank Leahy brought his Notre Dame team to open the ’53 season in Norman.  Leahy was thoughtful enough to bring Ralph Guglielmi, Neil Worden, Joe Heap and Fenwick’s own Johnny Lattner with him.  It was September 26, 1953 and Notre Dame beat Oklahoma 28-21.  Wilkinson responded and the Sooners finished Ike’s first term without another loss.

In 1957, Notre Dame was struggling under Terry Brennan. Buzzards were circling Cartier. The Irish were scheduled to visit Norman. The swift Sooners had won 47 in a row, the longest streak ever in the history of man’s inhumanity to man (and still the longest ever).  Revenge, sweet revenge was on the minds of Sooner Nation.  In they came, Eastward from Lone Wolf and Guymon, Southwest from Okmulgee and Claremore, up from the rich oil fields of Duncan and the rich bass population of Lake Eufala. It was November 16, 1957.

Jumping up off the sacrificial altar like Isaac did when Abraham halted the downstroke at Mount Moriah, the Irish refused to be the 48th sacrificial lamb and ended the revengefest with a sweet, short waltz by Dick Lynch around right end for a 7-0 final margin.  47 it was and remained. Not one win more.  The bookends were built, and yet remain.  (Yeah, we built two around UCLA’s 88 game hoop streak, but that was in South Bend.

Oh, the Sooners tried for revenge a decade later in 1966.  They had a wondrous middle guard named Granville Liggins, speed and ferocity at linebacker with Eugene Ross and Hary Hettmannsperger, and they planned to ambush the big slow Yankees from Notre Dame with Sooner Speed.  Uh-Uh. The big slow Yankees include Page, Duranko, Lynch, Hardy, Gmitter, Conjar, Seymour, Goeddeke and others.  Notre Dame 38-OU 0, and it really wasn’t that close.

Interestingly. Brian Kelly brought his Cincy Bearcats to Owen Field in 2008.  They lost 52-28, to the Sooner team that Florida beat for the BCS title, but they scored points and did not back down.


(1) Survive the opening onslaught.  Stoops played and coached for Hayden Fry, but Stoops credits Spurrier, for whom he served as defensive coordinator in the mid-90’s, for teaching Bob how to prepare for and win “big games.” Unlike Midwesterners like Hayes, Holtz and Schembechler, who always kept some powder dry for the second half of big games, Spurrier preferred to launch his most devastating ordnance early.  Stoops will have OU pull out all the stops, and attack aggressively early.  Notre Dame must merely survive the opening salvo in the first ten minutes, before the game settles in.

(2) The moment of truth for our secondary.  Landry Jones is a four year starter. He has a keen, mature eye for weakness and vulnerability.

(3) Jones will throw to tall, talented receivers, even though four of them, Metoyer (JC transfer) Saunders (the Fresno transfer), Brown (the PSU transfer) and freshman Durron Neal are relatively new to the Sooner system.  They have speed and can catch the ball. If you were to count the passes Metoyer caught as a JC, that Brown caught in State College, and Saunders caught at Fresno, it would be a large number. We will get a mega dose of four receiver sets. These are, by a margin, the best receivers the secondary will have seen, including, and in particular, on our own practice field.

(4) Diaco must both protect his secondary, and still  find ways to generate pressure against Landry, who is not too nimble. Of course, teams have been trying to sack Jones for four years, with limited success. This is NOT a vintage OU offensive line.

(5) OU is not a strong running team, but is opportunistic with talented Damien Williams leading the running backs.

(6) The Belldozer stops here.  Blake Bell has been a short yardage and goal line player.  Not against the Irish.  Cf Taylor, Stepfan.

(7) The Notre Dame offense must step up. Kansas State got 213 yards rushing and controlled the ball for 34 minutes. Klein had 79 of  those yards.  But Notre  Dame must run effectively, both to set up the pass and to keep Jones & Co. off the field.  A litmus test is that Notre Dame must significantly, materially outrush Oklahoma. It SEEMS like a prerequisite to a Notre Dame victory. Long drives could help.

(8) This is not the sack crew of old at OU.  There is no Gerald McCoy or Tommie Harris. A combination of good protection and moving Golson around should give him time to throw.

(9) Don’t underestimate Mike Stoops as a defensive coordinator.  He is a big improvement over the departed and overrated Brent Venables, now at Clemson, who took too many chances and gave up a lot of big plays.  Mike Stoops doesn’t do that. Remember, he shut out Florida State in the 2000 BCS championship. No easy yards, no easy points.

(10) Our toughest opponent, by a margin. So FAR!


This is only the second true road game for the Irish, the first having been in East Lansing.  The Irish have enjoyed home cooking and the insidious influence of backslapping and wide-eyed praise from their fellow students since September 15th.  Once they get on that plane, they get to look each other, and only each other,  in the eye once again, furloughing the student impulse and remembering that they are a team on a mission.

It is a mission that they all dreamed about and hoped for, an implied proviso in the Notre Dame bargain.  Still, it is surprising that they board the plane with a 7-0 record.  Well, it’s been said before at Notre Dame, with a different predicate, but the punch line is still apropos, Fighting Irish: This is that game.  You are that team.


You may also like


  1. I think it’s a front 10 or 12, and that’s been important. Springman, Day, Schwenke and about 5 or 6 LBs led by Teo

  2. kelly has to produce some offensive scheme that gets more points on the bd, and we need a new field goal kicker, cant he produce? diaco has big time

    1. An offensive scheme to produce more points, hmmmm, interesting thought. I wonder if a head coach with 20+ years experience and almost 200 career wins has thought of that.

  3. I agree with others about BYU. All week we heard about the dreaded trap game. Then ND comes out flat. A loss to BYU could have dashed our hopes of a BCS game.

    I hope and believe ND can beat Oklahoma, but I also know on paper this is the most complete team ND will face up to this point (possibly all year). So ND might come away with a loss. But that really won’t affect BCS prospects. ND could probably lose to OK and USC and go to the BCS (though USC looks more vulnerable this year). As long as they duke it out and beat who they have to beat (Pitt, BC and Wake Forest), and fight to the end with OK and USC, they’ll be a lock for a BCS bowl.

    That being said, I hope ND can put the beatdown on OK. I’d love to see ND in the NC talk (we’ll still probably need Alabama or Oregon to lose for that to happen, but you never know).

    1. And I think we will see Alabama and/or Oregon lose one this year. The second half of their seasons look MUCH tougher than the first half. My bet is that Bama lets one slip…

  4. JDH, I agree that OU will be surprised by our Front Seven. Don’t think they\ve seen anything like it since they played Florida.

    I thought our Front Seven would be good, but am shocked that it is as good as it is. Seriously, is it not true that all seven players, even the great Manti have SIGNIFICANTLY elevated their game in 2012?

    1. It’s quite incredible Duranko. They play with a toughness and expectation to win that we haven’t seen in a long time. Defense wins games, and championships, period.

      1. The last game day I seen this guy that had a sign that said “Mark May has a cheese d!*k” I laughed so hard hoping he would be able to get it on tv

  5. Shazam- I really like your analysis and think it’s right on target. 2 weeks in a row this team showed the character to come from behind and win. It speaks volumes and it’s been YEARS since we had that ability and mindset. A culture of losing is, day in day out, week in week out, being changed into a culture of winning again.

    1. JDH-Amen! I do not mean to be cliche but this team has shown it is ‘battle tested.’ They expect to succeed and that is so critical to the mental set that develops.

      As for OU? The Irish need to let them know right off the bat that “We came here hunting for you.” Not vice versa. Best to be the invader rather than the invaded.

      Go Irish! Hooah!

  6. They found a way to win, period. Granted, we cannot be a “second half team) against OU and USC. Lots of hard work each week with this offense will yield better results. If Brindza hits his field goals the game would have been much less hair raising.

    I believe the Oklahoma game is going to come down to turnovers. I think Oklahoma is going to be unpleasantly suprised at how hard it is to score on this ND defense. If Golson does not turn the ball over, we will leave Norman 8-0. We will need to score about 21 points to win. OU is 43rd in turnovers, the worst of all top 10 teams. ND is 10th. That’s my prediction.

    1. JDH,

      Turn overs are always crucial, but never more so than in big games against talented and well coached teams.

      There is just no margin for error. No forgiveness. No second chances.

      But strangely enough, I feel better about ND on the road agianst OU this week, than I did about last weeks game at home agianst an unranked BYU team.

      Maybe it was the mentality that last week we were playing not to lose, and this week, as the road team, and a 9.5 point, undefeated underdog, we can be more aggressive!

      If Kelly has anything in reserve, anything up his sleeve, a bag of surprises, this is the game to get them out.

      I would love to see something from our special teams.
      A kick off return, a punt reurn, a reverse on a return, a blocked punt or a blocked field goal.

      These plays are game breakers!
      Crowd silencers, momentum changers if you can get them.

      Just ask Frank Beemer and VT.
      A great, and always dangerous underdog team, because of their special teams play in big games.

      Even if our offense does it’s job, and the defense does theirs, we will probably still need a play or two from our special teams!

      So far our special teams have contributed by playing fudementally sound football and not beating themselves.
      Good snaps, good holds, good blocking, good coverage, solid tackeling, and smart decision making.

      Maybe this is a good spot to just turn them loose and go for it?

      1. “But strangely enough, I feel better about ND on the road agianst OU this week, than I did about last weeks game at home agianst an unranked BYU team.” -Shazamrock

        I feel the exact same way. I was nervous all week about BYU, because they are one of those teams. Always solid, can probably beat most top 10 teams on any given day if they play well. And the Stanford game was so physical and tiring.

        I think ND will rise to this occasion.

  7. What did I see against BYU?

    I saw Tommy Rees start and play the whole way, and with that, I saw a college head coach that made me very proud of Notre Dame, Their football team, and their approach to college athletics.

    We win or lose as a team. Next man in. Next guy up. It takes a total team effort for ND to succeed. Kelly said it, stands behind it, and I believe it.

    If I were Everett Golson’s parents, I would be very thankfull that my son plays for coach Brian Kelly.

    Kelly has his priorities in line… which starts with his love, concern, and the well being of all his players all the time.(as it should)

    In an age where winning is everything, and wise game decisions are often sacrificed in favor of selfishness and the almighty victory, it is refreshing to see a big time college coach treat his players like the fine young men that they truely are, and not some comodity or piece of meat.

    If EG played for LSU, or Alabama, or any of two dozen other programs accross the country, he would have started and played last Saturday.
    And maybe he was able to. But is that the wise thing? The responcible thing?

    I am so glade we are not Alabama or LSU.

    Anytime I hear about a concussion, or head injury, I can’t help but think of our own Dave Duerson. Could an ounce of prevention been the difference?

    There is of course, (Besides being 7-0) an upside to all of this.
    The offensive line was needed to step up. And did so for the second straight week against a very good defense.
    The team rallied around Tommy Rees.
    They learned how to win dispite adversity.
    We certainly are not a single running back team.
    They are the fighting Irish!
    And now, if cleared and deemed fully healthy, we have a well healed and well rested Everett Golson going into Norman Oklahoma!
    We have a team of players, not individuals. And that’s what it will take for continued success.

    1. Well we saw ohio state have their QB hospitalized and he was miraculously cleared with absolutely no signs of a concussion. Wow that gear they wear needs to be issued to all teams. Because it sure did look like a concussion a mild one at the very least

      1. Yes, and that very attitude of Urban Meyer and Co. is just the recipe to injure his qb for life. Coach Kelly made the right decision; he took care of his men first and foremost. Now EG will be 100% for the OU game.

      2. Agree on the call to put Rees in. I think Kelly did the right thing. If you have any doubt on a concussion, best not to chance it.

        My main point was that Golson is going to be a great quarterback and I agree with Kelly’s decision that he is the starter (unless injured). The talent is all their, he just needs grooming. All the problems he has (ball security mostly) can be coached. I’m a huge fan of the NY Giants and one thing Coach Coughlin teaches his team above all else is ball security. I think the staff will continue to work with Golson on that and he will get better.

  8. Toughest test this year is coming. This will be an uphill battle. I think ND can win if all the pieces come together. Would I be surprised at a loss, no. Oklahoma is likely the best team ND faces this year. I would be surprised if it’s a blowout though.

    Agree on Rees. He is great in relief and in a pinch, but for a whole game he is limited. I remember a lot of people saying how he has plateaud last year. I think we saw that against BYU. That is about as good as Rees gets, which is why he is not the answer at quarterback. I give him credit for helping win the game, he just is not the long term solution.

    Golson is going to be a great quarterback. The problems he is having do not surprise me in the least for a first year starter. There is a lot of raw talent there, and with some seasoning and continued practice, he is going to get better. Just the ability he has to roll out of the pocket, reset and still make a great pass makes him an exciting quarterback prospect. By the end of next year, this guy is going to be explosive all around.

    1. The growing pains and process are OK, but it is shame he doesn’t have a little more accuracy on the deep ball which would make things so make easier. Tommy doesn’t have the strength and EG doesn’t have the touch. This offense could be scary if that were not the case.

    2. Absolutely agree. Barring any unforeseen injury, EG is going to be a hell of a QB. It’s hard to get seasoned in 6 games. When he gets to a point where he is in command of this offense, I’m telling ya, watch out.

  9. Expect OU to fill the box with 8-9 defenders. They will make Golson throw the ball. I definitely agree that OU will come out swinging by throwing the ball over around 75% of the time. They will be very aggressive.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button