Notre Dame v. Duke ’16: Post Game 6-Pack

Photo: Matt Cashore // USA TODAY Sports
Photo: Matt Cashore // USA TODAY Sports

Notre Dame lost to Duke.. in football.  Let that sink in for a minute.  Notre Dame lost to Duke in football.  I don’t care how many games Duke won a year ago, they were 1-2 this season with losses to Wake Forest and Northwestern.  They are now 2-2 with a win over now 1-3 Notre Dame.

Notre Dame came out on fire on Saturday but by the end of the game the only thing left burning in South Bend were any hopes of salvaging what was already a lost season.  The Irish, ranked #10 just three weeks ago, dropped their third game of the season with the calendar still reading September.

Here’s this week’s post game 6-pack… which might need to turn into a post game 12 pack this season.

1. Brian Kelly has lost control.  Brian Kelly was more involved with the defense this week and he was shown on the sidelines huddling up with Brian Vangorder and the defense.  It didn’t look like he did a whole lot of talking though.  We’re four games into the season and Notre Dame’s 2016 season has completely unraveled and it doesn’t look like Kelly has any answers right now other than to remain stubborn.

This season is starting to have the feel of that ill-fated 2007 season under Charlie Weis.  Notre Dame lost a ton of talent from a 10 win team and instead of focusing on the fundamentals and coaching up a young team, the Irish grab bagged.  That is what this season is feeling like.  Much like 2007, nothing Kelly is saying after each loss is instilling any sort of confidence that he has the answers or a way to fix this mess.

Kelly has built up enough good will that his job is safe (for those calling for his head) but there really is no way he can stand pat with his staff.

2. This team simply doesn’t know how to tackle.  If there’s been a worse tackling team in the last 30 years of Notre Dame football, I don’t remember it.  For all the talk by Kelly of players being in position and not making plays, it’s on the defensive coaching staff to teach the players fundamentals throughout spring and fall camp.  In that department, they have failed miserably.

On the kick return for a touchdown, Notre Dame missed about three tackles including would should have been an easy one by Nick Coleman.  Time and time again Duke would appear to be headed for a 2-3 yard gain only to rip off 9 or 10.  The play that could sum up this game came when Duke quarterback Daniel Jones was flushed from the pocket and rolled left.  Senior captain SAM linebacker James Onwualu had Jones in his sights.  Jones ran right at Onwualu, put his head down, and drove him backwards for about an extra seven yards.  Onwualu tried to arm tackle Jones around his shoulder pads.

Notre Dame can simplify this defense all it wants and make all the in game adjustments in the world the rest of the season but it won’t matter.  Until this team learns how to tackle, we can expect opposing offenses to have their best offensive outputs of the season each weekend against this defense.

3. The secondary is still a train wreck.  Daniel Jones is a fine quarterback, but he’s not going to be on any Heisman watch lists any time soon.  Still, he lit up the Notre Dame secondary for 290 yards on 24 of 32 pass.  That’s a 75% completion percentage.  He completed 56% of his passes against Northwestern and 65% against Wake Forest.  In those two games he didn’t throw a single touchdown but did throw two interceptions.  Against Notre Dame he threw three touchdowns with just a single interception.

Notre Dame played pretty much anyone and everyone they could in the secondary.  They cycled through players all game long grasping for any answers they could find.  None were found.  Freshman corner Donte Vaughn made a nice interception in the third quarter, but other than that everyone took turns blowing assignments and getting burned.  The problems in the secondary were compounded by the poor tackling.  Duke completed a number of short passes that turned into good gains because of missed tackles.

Where Notre Dame goes from here is anyone’s guess.  There wasn’t a single player in the secondary who could have graded out well on Saturday and they will continue to be picked on until they show they can cover anyone.

4. Deshone Kizer is still streaky.  Kizer had a pretty stat line today but a lot of those stats were pretty empty.  He racked up a career high 381 yards passings but his two turnovers were killers and he missed a lot of throws at crucial times.  Duke’s defense was pretty terrible itself today but Notre Dame let them off the hook a number of times.

Kizer came out like a house on fire with more than 100 yards passing in the first five minutes of the game, but he was up and down for the final 55 minutes.  It’s terrible, but at this point Notre Dame needs Kizer to be perfect to win and it looks like he is playing like he knows that and it’s leading to some missed plays.

Kizer had a chance to lead two drives at the end of the game and neither were pretty.  He missed a WIDE open Equanimeous St. Brown on the final drive for what could have been a game changing play.  He took a sack on the previous drive that killed any momentum the Irish had and then threw a pick that set up Duke’s game winning score.

Kizer is still the most talented passer the Irish have had in a while, but he also still has a long way to go to live up to the #1 overall pick hype that started following his performance against Texas.

5. Notre Dame’s offensive line was extremely overrated.  For the second week in a row Notre Dame couldn’t run the football.  Last week they faced Michigan State so that’s a little understandable.  This week, they faced Duke.  Notre Dame couldn’t get the ground game going and it was clear that Kelly was hell bent on getting it going even when it looked like they could pass on Duke all day long.

Notre Dame ran for 153 yards but Josh Adams averaged just 4.3 yards a carry, Dexter Williams 4.8, and Tarean Folston 3.4.  The running lanes that were there the first two weeks just haven’t been there the last two.

6. This team does not handle adversity well.  Notre Dame jumped out to a quick 14-0 lead in the game’s first five minutes and it looked like Notre Dame might be on cruise control – as they should have been – but then the kick return for a touchdown happened and this team could never recovered the momentum.  Once things start to unravel for this team they get worse and worse.

Last week it was the third quarter when Michigan State ripped off 21 straight points before Notre Dame woke up.  This week they let Duke back in the game with the kick return and then a quick touchdown following a three and out from the offense.

Notre Dame has played in spurts at times this year and in every loss there was a period where the opposing team went on a run that Notre Dame could answer.  Against Texas the Longhorns scored 17 straight to build a 31-14 lead before the Irish stormed back.  Against Michigan State the Spartans scored 36 straight.  Today Duke went on a 28-7 run after the Irish jumped out to their 14-0 lead.

Parting Shots

  • Special teams were a trainwreck again this week.  Missed FG in a three point loss, the kick return for a touchdown, and no plays from the return units.
  • Nice to see Equanimeous St. Brown record his first career 100 yard game.  He has clearly become the #1 wide receiver on this team, but the sophomore’s fumble was a killer.
  • Notre Dame finally recorded a sack.  They have 1 on the season.  Duke has 17.
  • Notre Dame has now lost 5 of their last 6 games and back to back home games.
  • This defense could be historically bad but remember, pump the breaks.  It’s not the defensive coaching, right?
  • What happened to Chase Claypool?  Kid made plays last week but was MIA this weekend.
  • Can’t remember a game with this few penalties before.  The two teams combined for a total of three flags all game.
  • Harpoon’s Flannel Friday was the beverage of choice this week.  Unfortunately I can’t drown my sorrows with the rest of you this evening with a 10 mile run on tap for tomorrow morning.



You may also like


  1. Chuckie,
    When Garry Faust came in, George Kelly and Joe Yonto bailed out. They had been here with Ara and stayed for Devine, but not for Garry, for whatever reason.
    Notre Dame made them “Non-coaching Administrators” to use your term – and they stayed around until death, for all practical purposes (Yonto made a cameo appearance on the practice field in Holtz’s first year).
    But 1. Those guys had been Notre Dame men for anywhere from 15 years to 45 years (Yonto played for us).
    and 2. They were not head coaches.
    Keeping BK around would probably be inappropriate and maybe awkward.
    The better answer is for BK to right the ship and be the hire finish what he started.
    If not, and I think, but certainly do not know, that he has to do big things next year or he’ll be replaced.
    He will not leave the cupboard bare, like Coach Ty almost did, and overall, the program will be fairly well situated for a step up. That’s why I still like him. But he needs to produce, and I think he knows it.
    Bruce Curme

  2. The administrative improvements introduced by Brian Kelly are true advances. However, he has proved incapable of coaching. He cannot even SEE the coaching problems in defense, running game, and special teams.

    Why not keep him as “non-coaching administrator”, and hire someone to coach the game?

  3. Frank, I agree with, and would like to add to your “parting shots” in this article please:

    * ND is a physically weak team and is out muscled in most all phases

    * ND is not physical at the point of attack, and lacks in hard hitting football aggressiveness and skills

    * ND plays with little passion

    * ND defense causes very few turnovers (especially fumbles) and sacks totals are a joke

  4. I have been watching 7 years under Kelly and noticed a pattern repeating over and over with his teams. Every game Notredame plays they play very well in all 3 areas offense, defense and special teams but only in spurts. I think what the problem is Kelly and his coaching staff are slow to non existent in making in game adjustments on the fly. When defenses adjust to what Notre Dame is doing we don’t have counter moves. Same thing on defense. All games ebb and flow= good things happen, bad things happen. The Saban’s and Meyer’s of the world make great adjustments. Kelly and his staff do not.

  5. I know I keep saying I’m finished posting, but this loss really sticks. I keep hoping I wake up and find out it was just a bad dream, that ND really clobbered Duke 45-3. I had my own head up my own behind for too long. If others want to call me names or berate me for switching sides, I’m a big boy. I can take it. And to those that can still find it somewhere to continue to support BK, I hope you’re right. I really do. I no longer believe it, but if some miracle occurs, BK does a complete 180 and next year they are celebrating an NC, I’ll freely come on here and admit I was wrong. Sadly, I just don’t see anyway forward under BK.

  6. Swarbrick is safe. He’s a godsend and saved our football program more than anyone except perhaps Lou. BVG needs to be fired. If Kelly won’t do it, then he needs to be fired. Sorry, Kelly’s done a great job getting the program back on track, but he needs to show the ability to get to the next level, and he just hasn’t done that so far. He’s earned the right to try and fix the issues, but it has to start with BVG. All teams have new kids each year, and “we’re young” just doesn’t cut it for a major program with the same head coach for 7 years. He should’ve recruited better to have a steady flow of talent.

  7. Losing to Duke should be unacceptable. No ands, ifs, or abouts. I get the feeling that perspective is not shared by the coaching staff at ND.

  8. Damian,

    Don’t buy into the “Debbie Downer” rhetoric. That’s used the by the perpetual head up the ass crowd on here. I prefer to be called a “Debbie Downer” than live with the brown walls of my large intestine as my en suite.

    Now, if only Bad Breath could get his head out of his ass!

    Bad Breath according to Bad Breath=Smarter, wittier, better writer, more knowledge about football than the rest of us on here combined.

    Bad Breath according to reality=Self-righteous, self-delusional, megalomaniac, masochist, sodomite.

  9. Gotcha. I feel like a Debbie Downer. I so wanted to believe in BK. But how can I anymore? As Frank noted, this has ominous feelings of 2007. It’s scary. Losing to Duke? Now that calls into question NC State, Navy, Army, USC. I mean forget beating Stanford or Miami. Do they lose out? I figure they’ll probably win a few games just because Kizer will probably bail them out here and there. But a losing season is no longer out of the question. WTF.

  10. Frank,

    I nominate Bad Breath for the six pack. He’s this site’s self-styled football genius. He knows everything about ND football. I mean, he knows that BK runs a “hybrid spread O.” I bet you didn’t know that?!

    He’s SO BRILLIANT! I mean he knows how to spell cunt! I don’t know what that has to do with football acumen, but, hey, what can I say?

  11. Just busting on “southside” who calls everyone he disagrees with a “Debbie Downer”. He’s a Patriots fan from Boston.

    You’re a “Debbie Downer” now, Damian. Just warning you that your onetime allies are going to get nasty with the name calling.

    Just warning you.

  12. BK never had it. Minor league coach before ND. Not much presence. Anger management problem. Bad dresser. ND has not recognized a great coach since Holtz. They always seem desparate and have to settle for second or third best. I have no idea what is wrong with them or the A.D. It is almost like a foreign agent has infiltrated ND football and is succeeding at the job to be sure they will never win another nat. champ. Think about it–last one 1988. If BK does not go, forgetitaboutit. I won’t be watching anymore. What an embarrasement for this alum. Maybe it is time to put some Prostestants in charge!

  13. Ok, I know I said I was done, but I’m not following the Patriots link here?? What does the Patriots have to do with ND? Not that I disagree with the sentiment (I have no love for the Pats and was thrilled my Giants beat them twice in the SB).

  14. You are all such “Debbie Downers”! When I find my Rosary I’ll pray that you’ll see that BK and this team are really, really great. ND is 1-3 after losing to Duke, what else could you “Debbie Downers” possibly want!

    By the way, I’ll also pray that Bill Belicheat and Co. won’t spend too much time in Purgatory. Of course, they might end up in Hell because of their pact with the Devil. No prayers can help them then!

  15. BTW sorry for the misspells (a little agitated someone is using my ID) but mind=mine and piece=peace. Now that really is the end of my comments.

  16. I don’t know who is using my ID but comment number 3 is mind, number 5 is not. I don’t know how to prove that though the moderators will know by my e-mail address.

    I said my piece on number 3, and have nothing further to add, so if that someone continues to post with my name, they are not my posts.

  17. It’s over for me. I have tried to back BK, as late as last week thinking, if we just fixed the defense (with a new DC) that would probably due the trick. Losing to Duke, TO DUKE, that was it for me. Never in a million years did I think they lose to Duke. BK has lost me. That doesn’t mean a whole lot in the grand scheme, except to say that when he lost me, a pretty strong supporter up to now, that’s pretty bad. Very disappointing to me, because I truly thought he was the one to bring us back to the promised land. ND finally got it’s man on the first try, a coach with a successful track record up to then, who got 2 star players to overachieve. How he could not do the same with 4 and 5 star players I will never know. And where does ND go from here? Where is that coach to bring ND back to elite status? I don’t know, but I no longer believe BK is that man. Very sad.

  18. I don’t know what to say. Sixty years old and starting in 1994 mediocre football. This is not the Notre Dame I grew up with. I couldn’t watch the game because I just moved yesterday and my tv isn’t set up yet. I wasn’t about to go to a bar and watch this garbage. If Kelly is going to stay I recommend the following changes. Booker – gone. He has done nothing to make the special teams great and the tight ends under him have regressed big time. Vangorder – gone. He makes Gary Darnell look good. Todd Lyght- gone. Db’s are clueless. Cole Luke looks like a completely different player than 2 years ago. Denbrock – have him take over all the receivers tight ends included. Sanford- give him complete control of the offense, play calling, philosophy, scheme etc. Kelly oversees entire team in 2017. If no turn around in 2017 Kelly and Swarbrick get the boot.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Back to top button