Notre Dame Football 2018 Stock Report: Week 2

Whenever you think Brian Kelly has figured it out, he lets you know you have no idea. Following last weeks big win against Michigan, the formula seemed to be in place. Lead with the run, challenge defenses with Brandon Wimbush’s legs, throw over the top of them with play action. After all, why play Wimbush if you have other plans in mind? It all made sense.

So naturally, Notre Dame countered the conventional wisdom with 35 drop backs from the quarterback against overmatched Ball State, and just five called Wimbush runs. Wimbush delivered the performance you’d expect with that kind of ratio, with some dazzling throws and some throws that could be characterized as whatever the opposite of dazzling is. He finished the day with 297 passing yards, three interceptions, four sacks, and 8 yards on those five called runs.

As you’d suspect, the offense was disjointed, finishing with 414 total yards, with just 117 rushing yards, the three turnovers, and a missed field goal. Brian Kelly, welcome back.


The Linebackers

I’m including Asmar Bilal with the two other stars, because he’s played really good football the first two weeks as well. Te’Von Coney is on pace to finish the regular season with 144 tackles and 21 tackles for loss, Bilal with 54 tackles, and Tranquill 96 tackles. Notre Dame’s defense (and team) aren’t going to be anything without stellar play from Tranquill and Coney, so this is great to see. Bilal though has been a surprise, and is really going to play a big role when Stanford comes to town. He was once thought of as someone stealing snaps till Notre Dame goes nickel and put Shaun Crawford on the field. With the injury to Crawford, Bilal playing well become more of a necessity and he has delivered.

Miles Boykin

Despite a deflected pass off of his hands that ended in an interception, Boykin was key to the passing game, with several big catches over the middle to give Notre Dame life. He finished with six receptions and 119 yards, looking every bit like the reliable target the Irish offense needs him to be.

Jalen Elliott

Quite the turn of events for Elliott, who figured to be the back up to Nick Coleman at safety next to Alohi Gilman, then Crawford went down, Coleman moved to nickel, and Elliott was the starter again. He responded yesterday with his first two career interceptions and seven tackles. After five tackles against Michigan, included one that stole the soul of a wolverine tight end, Elliott has made the most of his early opportunity. Elliott was one of my Now or Never features over the summer, along with Bilal, and I mentioned regarding both of them to watch out for the second season post-BVG gains we might see. Both needed development out of high school, neither got it under their original coordinator, and it looks like competent coaching has paid off mightily for both players.

Jafar Armstrong/Theo Riddick comparisons

It was all on display Saturday, with Armstrong bursting up the middle for long gains on the ground, and running seam and corner routes out of the slot to gash the defense through the air. He has even taken to sticking the ball out for needless reasons while going into the end zone a la Riddick, so he has fully embraced the role.


The Offensive Line

They struggled against Michigan, which was understandable because Michigan has got some real dudes on defense. However, when the same struggles appear against Ball State, there is a problem. The Cardinals registered 10 tackles for loss against Notre Dame, including four sacks, and four other quarterback hurries. They were in the backfield for Notre Dame consistently, costing them about 50 yards in lost yardage. In 41 carries against Ball State, the running game produced just 117 yards, 2.9 per carry. That’s not good. Even without running their quarterback, the line should be able to produce more than that. It goes without saying, Notre Dame won’t be anything this season if that group doesn’t get it figured out. They have introduced new players in new positions, so this wasn’t totally unexpected. But struggles like this against one of the worst defenses they’ll see doesn’t bode well.

The Kicking Game

Yoon missed a field goal from inside 50 yards, Tyler Newsome continues to throw in a dud punt every so often, and Jonathan Doerer can’t seem to figure out how to kickoff. The most troubling is Yoon, because he’s the best of the three, and because Newsome and Doerer have struggled before, so it’s kind of a known thing. However, if Notre Dame is going to employ a full-time special teams coach, then this sort of thing can’t be happening, full stop.

Figure out how to kickoff the way you want, figure out how to get your senior captain to be more consistent. This riff raff on kickoff has already cost them a touchdown.

You may also like


  1. If playing the guy who can “best help us win” is so old and universally accepted that it is practically a cliché, why in the God damned hell isn’t Yoon kicking off?

    BGC ’77 ’82

    1. Agree Bruce. I highly doubt Yoon is going to “get tired” kicking the ball out of the endzone on kickoffs maybe 5 or 6 times a game. That’s what he trains for. Another head scratcher.

  2. Have we learned yet that teams coming into Notre Dame Stadium resent being compared to cannon fodder, chicken field or a glorified scrimmage? Please, somebody punch Vandy in the mouth and then sit on them before they realize they actually have a chance to win. Please, just one screen, one counter or trap, or even a Philly Philly would be acceptable, but stop those head-on charges over tackle.

  3. Greg,

    This is well written and accurate, especially your opening summary. My favorite was “Naturally, Notre Dame countered the conventional wisdom” line. It basically speaks to Kelly and why he might not ever be an elite coach. I’m not giving up all hope on him but it’s this kind of stupid crap that holds him back and makes all ND fans scratch our heads. I do think the program is getting better and better and we are bringing in some great recruits but if Kelly holds them back because of terrible coaching, it’s tough to stay fully supportive of him. I truly felt bad for Wimbush this game.

  4. Instead of saying the Kicking Game can we just say Special Teams?!? Brian Polien although a great recruiter continues to have problems coaching this unit and he has for years.

  5. Special teams is just a mess, and seems to have been all during the BK regime. They have good individual elements. Yoon is usually a reliable FG kicker for instance (I’m not really worried about the missed FG yet, as long as it doesn’t become a trend). But as an overall unit they have not been stellar. That’s a real concern.

    This game I think justifies those of us that look at ND this year with a more critical eye, not buying any hype until the season is over. That doesn’t mean I’ll root against ND. I want them to win every game of course. But I won’t be buying into any playoff hype until the season is over and they’re sitting at 11-1 or better.

  6. Looking past the next two, the Irish will absolutely need Dexter Williams to stay even with the Cardinal. They have a soft underbelly and can be run on. That will be the way to finally beat them. It will be a fight between Coney and Love to the outside. The defense will have to step up even more than Michigan.
    Vandy led by their talkative , boasting Coach will come into Knute Rockne Stadium thinking they can pull off a upset. The Irish must get their act together, no more experimenting and just play simple hard nosed football and beat up the Commodores.

    1. AFTER last week your getting way, way ahead of yourself GK!! To count any game as a win with the play of the O-LINE and QB is a big mistake!! ITS gonna b 1 game at a time this o-line needs help!!

      1. NDCM, Sorry. I just couldn’t help going there. And Myself and other Irish fans have been so frustrated that the Cardinal can beat us. I know I was thinking to far ahead and must concentrate at the game at hand. Maybe that’s whats wrong with this team thus far.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Back to top button